About Contact Archives RSS Columns Photos

Look who’s defending the rich now

By Michelle Malkin  •  April 29, 2005 11:11 AM

The left side of the blogosphere has gone into full-blown spin mode regarding the effects of President Bush’s Social Security indexing proposal.

Here’s Josh Marshall:

let’s state specifically what this to-some-sexy-sounding proposal offers: steep benefit cuts for all but the lowest income Americans and meager increases in benefits for them. It’s hard to see how there’s anything particularly progressive about gutting Social Security for the entire middle class.

Armando at Daily Kos:

Yes, give the wealthiest a huge tax cut by repealing the estate tax. Screw the middle class by cutting their future social security benefits. Typical BushCo approach.

And Atrios:

Bush has not proposed increasing benefits for very low income workers. He’s just proposed not cutting them - and cutting everyone else’s a lot.

As I noted below, Bush’s indexing plan guarantees middle- and upper-income retirees the same level of benefits they get now (after adjusting for inflation). Their benefits would not, however, grow above the rate of inflation, as is the case under the status quo.

The savings would be used to allow working people of all income levels to set aside some of their Social Security taxes into private retirement funds. Under reasonable assumptions about investment returns, those accounts could be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars 40 years from now.

There was a time when liberals could be counted on to defend the interests of working class Joes. Marshall and the others are now taking the exact opposite position. They are saying, in effect, that ensuring ever-increasing benefits for well-to-do retirees is more important than promoting the financial well-being of young working people.

Posted in: Kos, Social Security

See what others have said

Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.

Trackbacks

  1. Decision '08
  2. Northshore Politics
  3. ResurrectionSong
  4. Enlightenment Reactionary
  5. Napablogger
  6. Ace of Spades HQ
  7. Silent Running
  8. Musing Minds
  9. The Palmetto Pundit
  10. Don Singleton
  11. The (not so) Daily Me
  12. virtual guy
  13. credit reports
  14. best skin care line
  15. home based party business
  16. news blog
  17. protein diet
  18. teprast fill 554 extracti
  19. air ambulance florida reached
  20. free vedic astrology reading tracked
  21. basketball betting strategy redirected
  22. reverse auction uk gauged

Trackback URL

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Daily Kos diarrhist urges you to pray for Michelle’s death

June 23, 2008 06:50 PM by see-dubya

114 Comments | 1 Trackback

Like school in July.

Bodies of two kidnapped US contractors found in Iraq

March 24, 2008 11:58 PM by Michelle Malkin

21 Comments | 2 Trackbacks

Ronald J. Withrow and John Roy Young, RIP.

The cost of doing nothing about exploding entitlements

February 4, 2008 12:12 PM by Michelle Malkin

57 Comments | 0 Trackbacks

$$$$$$$.

“Democrats for Romney:” The Kos factor in the Michigan primary

January 14, 2008 02:24 PM by Michelle Malkin

71 Comments | 7 Trackbacks

Nutroots election prank.

Kos advocates election mischief in Michigan

January 11, 2008 12:08 PM by Michelle Malkin

57 Comments | 5 Trackbacks

Kos + Rove + Newsweek = Zzzzzzzz

November 15, 2007 03:15 PM by Michelle Malkin

34 Comments | 6 Trackbacks

Soporific.

Daily Kossacks + Pete Stark = Nutroots mutual admiration society

October 18, 2007 09:23 PM by Michelle Malkin

66 Comments | 5 Trackbacks

Unhinged birds of a feather.


Categories: Kos, Social Security


Hotline On Call

» LIVESTRONG

Hotline On Call

» Novak Hits Pedestrian ...