Did You Know...



By thisistwitchy  •  April 29, 2005 11:11 AM

The left side of the blogosphere has gone into full-blown spin mode regarding the effects of President Bush’s Social Security indexing proposal.

Here’s Josh Marshall:

let’s state specifically what this to-some-sexy-sounding proposal offers: steep benefit cuts for all but the lowest income Americans and meager increases in benefits for them. It’s hard to see how there’s anything particularly progressive about gutting Social Security for the entire middle class.

Armando at Daily Kos:

Yes, give the wealthiest a huge tax cut by repealing the estate tax. Screw the middle class by cutting their future social security benefits. Typical BushCo approach.

And Atrios:

Bush has not proposed increasing benefits for very low income workers. He’s just proposed not cutting them – and cutting everyone else’s a lot.

As I noted below, Bush’s indexing plan guarantees middle- and upper-income retirees the same level of benefits they get now (after adjusting for inflation). Their benefits would not, however, grow above the rate of inflation, as is the case under the status quo.

The savings would be used to allow working people of all income levels to set aside some of their Social Security taxes into private retirement funds. Under reasonable assumptions about investment returns, those accounts could be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars 40 years from now.

There was a time when liberals could be counted on to defend the interests of working class Joes. Marshall and the others are now taking the exact opposite position. They are saying, in effect, that ensuring ever-increasing benefits for well-to-do retirees is more important than promoting the financial well-being of young working people.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Posted in: Uncategorized

Salesmanship fail: Rep. Patrick Murphy channels his inner Neville Chamberlain to pitch Iran deal

August 31, 2015 08:57 PM by Doug Powers


Honesty is the best policy

Super Sunday open thread: I’m just in it for the food this year

February 1, 2015 02:29 PM by Doug Powers


Plus whatever else you want to talk about

Hypocrisy whopper: Warren Buffett helps finance Burger King’s US tax reduction

August 26, 2014 10:24 AM by Doug Powers


“Economic patriotism”

The novels of Carole Malkin

August 15, 2014 01:51 PM by Michelle Malkin

Screen Shot 2014-08-15 at 3.53.07 PM

Obama admin/Israeli relations summed up in one photo

July 23, 2014 08:31 PM by Doug Powers


Reporting for awkward

Categories: Uncategorized

Follow me on Twitter Follow me on Facebook