The threat from the open northern border
I’m glad to see conservative Republican Senators on the floor this morning pushing bona fide border security and immigration enforcement measures (see here and here for background).
Comprehensive immigration enforcement reform, however, means paying attention to all our ports of entry–air, land, and sea. And all our borders–southern and northern. In Invasion , I recounted how Border Patrol agents would stick orange rubber cones on vast, unguarded swaths of the northern border. I’ve reported on the security threat posed to the U.S. by Canada’s lax asylum policies, jihadi-friendly positions, and McCustoms’ attitude. Daniel Stoffman’s “Who Gets In” diagnosed the systemic ills of Canada’s immigration system, which in turn, poses dangers to us.
A new DHS report reveals that little has changed. Via USAT:
Montana has the longest unprotected border in the world with a sparse population and vast terrain on the U.S. side and 90% of Canada’s population within 100 miles on the other. That makes the area vulnerable to illegal crossings into the United States by terrorists and extremists groups, the Helena Independent Record says.
While the state’s northern border population is sparse, the area is highly traveled. More than 70 million international travelers and 35 million vehicles crossed the northern border last year. Agents made about 4,000 arrests and intercepted 40,000 pounds of illegal drugs, the newspaper reports.
“There is an undisputed presence in Canada of known terrorist affiliate and extremist groups, including Hezbollah, Hamas and the Armed Islamic Group of Algeria,” according to a report from the Department of Homeland Security.
With Google Earth revealing 58 unmanned roads or trails leading in and out of the country, local law enforcement say they lack the manpower to properly guard the border. Currently, there are 190 officers working the northern border.
The Helena Independent Record has an excellent investigation of northern border vulnerabilities here.
The DHS northern border report is here.
And here’s a reminder of how vigilance–and behaviorial profiling–at the northern border saved untold American lives: Remember Diana Dean.
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Fast and Furious showdown: Holder/Obama defend bloody culture of contempt; Update: Fortress Holder, Stonewall City; vid clips added, Dems advise, “Don’t answer”
February 2, 2012 09:16 AM by Michelle Malkin
158 CommentsObama and Jan Brewer Have Words on Airport Tarmac; Update: Brewer Book Sales Skyrocket
January 25, 2012 09:54 PM by Doug Powers
165 CommentsGingrich channels open-borders SEIU; Rubio rebukes; Update:Newt retreats
January 25, 2012 10:56 AM by Michelle Malkin
155 CommentsObama heads to Disney World to push looser visa policies
January 17, 2012 01:14 PM by Michelle Malkin
95 CommentsObama’s “Razist” Lobbyist Moves Up
January 13, 2012 06:29 AM by Michelle Malkin
233 CommentsThe Year in Obama Scandals — and Scandal Deniers
December 28, 2011 12:04 PM by Michelle Malkin
122 CommentsThe murder of Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry: One year ago today
December 14, 2011 11:11 AM by Michelle Malkin
70 CommentsSupreme Court to Decide Arizona Immigration Law
December 12, 2011 01:18 PM by Doug Powers
57 CommentsRick Perry and the Macaca Media
October 3, 2011 10:08 AM by Michelle Malkin
91 Comments
Categories: Immigration
Pundit & Pundette
» Obama's war on conscience, cont'd
Redstate
» Media Matters

Hot Air
» National Review to Newt: Get out
AmSpecBlog
» Explosion Near Israeli Embassy in India


NRO
» Santorum’s Turn











4000 arrests. You can imagine these 190 guys and gals are worked to death. DHS is a joke. Good job up there guys.
While there are ways in and out of every country in the world, I don’t know of any nation that has as porous a border as the United States.
The next attack, the terrorists won’t really need visas, will they? Slip in on one of the established routes, preferably the northern one, since it is more open, and you’re halfway to accomplishing your mission.
Exactly. And the fact that there haven’t been any large-scale, successful attacks since 9/11 is more a factor of luck than anything else. How much longer can our luck hold out? I’m thinking not much longer.
OK call me a nut for my conspiracy theories, but maybe when Bambi H. O. becomes President, we will find out just what kind of “change” he has in mind. Don your burkas ladies.
I fully understand and appreciate the Jihadist threat from our northern neighbor very well, that’s why when I demand a border fence/barrier from by lying crapweasel Congress critters I always include both of our land borders requiring control and enforcement.
Maybe there really is no such thing as an unmixed blessing.
I’ve always thought that we’ve been blessed to have to comparatively weak and benign neighbors. Imagine a world in which we had a land border with Germany, China, or the old Soviet Union. The idea of “the world’s longest unguarded border” would, if expressed out loud, qualify for an immediate diagnosis of insanity.
On the other hand, we can be – and probably are – victims of the very same blessing. The reason why we don’t need to maintain 40 divisions along our northern border is also why it’s so easy for anyone to just stroll in.
Similarly, we are also victims of our own success since 9/11 – i.e., in not having any more spectacular attacks on our soil. The sense of urgency is gone.
Right after 9/11 Bush had the political capital to have pushed for, and gotten, whatever was needed to effectively protect the borders. But not any more. And none of the current presidential candidates are expressing much interest in border security, either.
It’ll take another major, mass-casualty attack here to focus the politicians’ attention again. How pitiful is it to have to wonder just how many must die within our borders to finally justify defending those borders?
They have a lot of nerve calling it the “Department of Homeland Security” as inept as Chertoff and his bunch seem to be.
Oh! And, let us not forget the imbecils in elected office in D.C.
And you can imagine how many that should be stopped and arrested get through.
As highways, means of transportation have improved coupled with the explosion of border crossings, 1900 agents for such a long border would’t be enough. 19,000 might be a more realistic number.
A hearty thank you for all the hard working border patrol agents who really do take their job seriously in spite of the counterproductive bureaucrats they work for.
I knew the DHS would fail because it’s a bureau; when have any of us seen a bureau do its job?
I also knew it would fail because they put PA Gov. Tom Ridge in charge; he was equally useless as governor.
I deal with the Canadian immigration system on a daily basis. It’s not corrupt but inept. Work permits are bought and sold overseas for as little as $2,000. There is nothing like a DNS, so once a person gets into Canada, they are here to stay. I’ve heard dozens of cases of people coming into Canada with dubious study permits and disappearing. I work in a related business and my client has one such person now – a Korean guy who vanished 2 weeks ago. But there’s no one to call. No immigration enforcement, no DNS, no police, no one at all who cares or is responsible.
As for crossing the border? I know one person who got lost on a beach south of Vancouver and ended up in the USA. He bought cigarettes and came back with no hassles.
I’ve heard the water border is even worse. The border there is apparently voluntary. There is no inspection at all on boats coming to and from Canada’s Gulf Islands. And the nearest landfall from the Gulf Islands? Whidbey Island Naval Air station.
Having a son stationed at Whidbey, I’ve figured he was pretty safe (except when he’s sent out on a carrier with his planes), but now I have something else to worry about.
Thanks Chertoff.
I recommend everyone read Michelle’s book Invasion. It was written in Michelle’s reader friendly style, well researched and frightening in its factual content.
You’ll be mad when you find out a lot of stuff you didn’t know and wonder why this problem is being left unattended.
Why do terrorist need visas when the borders are wide-open? One day another attack will occur. When we learn that they crossed the border, there will be a big “hue and cry” to close the borders. The politicians will make promises, pass bills, and show sympathy…until the population forgets, then ignore everything, once again. They know it’s more important to liberalize (socialize) the country first, before anything else can be tackled. That seems to be what people want, first.
Right on, Boomer. I’ve been saying that for years now: Fences on both borders. After the entire Canuck border guard abandoned ship in the face of two armed ILLEGAL criminals making for a Washington State crossing, there was no question we’re on our own as far as border security. I’ve also read they use unarmed college students [probably a good idea not to give them guns] in the summer. The Canadian professional guards can be pretty threatening to American citizens, on the other hand. The Canadian liberal government has dismantled the military. The current minority Conservative government will not be able to overcome the socialist bent of the populace, Small Dead Animals and Angry notwithstanding, to repair that situation anytime soon. Modeling old Europe seems to provide them some sense of differentiation and superiority. Good for them. The denigration of “W” and the U. S. by Cretian and Martin and their cadre and the ongoing hyperbole coming from their liberals and the CBC lead me to boycott all things Canadian. In the meantime, let’s take care of business below the 49th and buy American. We have plenty of lumber and beer produced domestically.
I think the legislative authorized 784 miles of Duncan Hunter caliber fence is the Chicago Cubs of fence building. Wait until next year. America has squandered vast treasury rebuilding, rebuilding, Iraq. We have pounded hundreds of billions into that rat hole whith no end in sight and we have not even the 1.4 billion authorized to build the Duncan Hunter. Iraq gets 360 times the amount being spent for no fence. We must now develop new words of skepticism: una sensación o una actitud que una no sabe la verdad, la verdad, o el trustworthiness alguien o algo.
You can have illegal migration and chamberpot immigration, or national security.
Seems to me Bush has shown where his priorities lie. Would a person concerned about national security appoint an affirmative action nincompoop to the post of National Security Adviser? Would he leave the borders open?
DHS needs more diversity in their staff. Perhaps Cong. Watt could take some of the people he has in mind for staffing to the Montana line bordering Canada and have a long camp out.
We got to be careful how we secure the northern border. We better not make it too hard to get out.
That cone picture is funny. That’s exactly how the border security is at some points between Canada and the US. A lot of that border is more remote than the Mexican border.
The cone picture made me laugh out loud, thanks. I’ve got a great Canadian border story, but I won’t share it here.
Well, it is true. The Northern Border is wide open. The USBP is sending in reports that are a spin of the actual facts. Facts that I have tried to report to M.M to no avail. She has not returned any emails of information on the northern border.
So, the fact that Congress and the Senate do not want to hear it along with the so called “Right Wing Media” who will not listen…we will not see any solutions there…in the near future. I went to the HUGE success in April to DC for the “HOLD THEIR FEET TO THE FIRE” which, I do not recall seeing M.M at. We had some 40 radio shows there. heck, even Lou Dobbs sent a film crew. Sean Hannity? No show. M.M. I did not see her.
We all went there on our own dime. Spending our time and money to help stop the amnesty. I reported to about 20 leaders about the northern border and the fences. They all suggested that fences do not work. Then, I told them what I did for a living. They quickly ended the session.
I am glad to see M.M. post something about the northern border. I would love to fill her in on the truth up here, without sugar coating it.