Complaint filed against Elton John/Hillary fundraiser
Judicial Watch has filed a complaint with the FEC over that Elton John/Hillary fundraiser. Not that there’s anyone actually at the FEC who’ll do anything about it, what with the stalemate over FEC nominees rendering the office completely dysfunctional. Oh, well. Here’s the press release:
Judicial Watch, the public interest group that investigates and prosecutes government corruption, announced today that it filed a formal complaint with the Federal Election Commission (FEC) related to a fundraising concert by musician Sir Elton John on behalf of Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign. Elton John, a foreign national, is prohibited by federal law, from making any contribution to a federal, state or local election campaign.
“Recent news reports suggest that Hillary Clinton and Hillary Clinton for President have accepted an in-kind contribution from a foreign national, Sir Elton John, in contravention of federal electon laws,” Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton stated in an April 14 letter to the Office of the General Counsel for the FEC. “On behalf of Judicial Watch and its supporters, I hereby request that the FEC investigate this matter.”
According to a press release issued by the Clinton campaign, the expressed intent of the concert was to raise funds for Hillary’s campaign for president. In the release, Elton John is quoted as saying, “I’m excited to support Hillary by performing at what will be a truly memorable night.”
Press reports also show that Sir Elton John, on March 17, 2008, through the Clinton campaign, sent out a mass email announcing the concert and soliciting support. The Elton John concert took place on April 9, 2008 and raised more than $2.5 million (from the sale of 5,000 tickets) for Hillary Clinton and Hillary Clinton for President.
However, according to 2 U.S.C. § 441e, “Contributions and donations by foreign nationals,” it is illegal for any foreign national to “make a contribution or donation of money or other thing of value…in connection with a Federal, State or local election.” The Washington Times reported March 27, 2008, that a “1981 FEC decision prohibited a foreign national artist from donating his services in connection with fundraising for a U.S. Senate campaign.”
“It looks as if Elton John, a foreign national, gave a valuable, in-kind contribution to Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign, which is prohibited by law. The FEC and other authorities need to take appropriate action and investigate Hillary Clinton, her campaign, and Elton John,” stated Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton.
The full complaint is here.
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Trackbacks
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Categories: Hillary Clinton
Legal Insurrection
» In The End: No Public Option, No Abortions, No Pelosi, No Reid
The Powers That Be
» Obama: ‘Don’t Jump to Conclusions’ About Ft. Hood; Immediately Jumps to ConclusionsLegal Insurrection
» NY Times Names NamesThe Powers That Be
» A Picture is Worth a Trillion Dollars and Lots of Lost FreedomRiehl World View
» Health Care Bill In A Few WordsPundit & Pundette
» Not a huge victoryJustOneMinute
» Ari Fleischer Needs To Cowboy UpThe Other McCain
» Debunking Frank Rich's NY23 fantasies
Hmmm, I don’t want to be a nitpicker, but I do think it’s a valid point.
I agree–this is silly. Was his opening song “The Bitch is Back?” If so, then maybe there should be an investigation after all.
What are talking about?
It seems to me you lived your life like a scandal in the wind…
So Sir John, it’s not that we hate women, it’s just that we hate foreign celebrities interfering in our elections.
We have enough “celebrities” of our own telling us how to vote based on their entertainment induced egos.
I don’t think you understood the post. Or maybe I just don’t understand you.
I think Judicial Watch’s complaint is worth looking into. The point is there’s no one around at the FEC to do it.
Actually I’m surprised it took this long.
Business as usual for Clinton, to bad nothing will happen. The clintons are”teflon turds” nothing sticks to them.
This is very close to what happned, except it was a Presidential campaign. I don’t think they’ll do anything about it. If they would Goracle would be in jail for the Buddhist-gate.
Well, the Clintons have probably been taking foreign money for so long over the past 8 years, they didn’t think this concert would pose a problem.
You’re certainly right about that, walterc. I’m sick of “celebs” telling us how to eat, drink, live and vote. Yet, when you look at their lives, all you can show is disgust; between the dictator-coddling, marriages and divorces faster than news can be printed, rehab vacations every couple of months, and anti-American behavior. But, I can understand why Clinton likes Elton (no “sir” from me). When you’re broke and losing, you get money from wherever you can get it. The MSM is so bad, that if either one deliberately killed their spouse, the news would be about it being driven by a “right wing conspiracy”, done in secret by conservatives.
His presence was the value. The performance a “thing of value”? HA
It looked like he needed some sunlight and a good visit to the tailor.
Tiger ha! very good, #4…. lol
I agree Michelle that the currently feckless FEC will do nothing … however … had this been a concert to raise funds for John McCain the complaint would have been filed before the concert was over …
I am shocked, shocked I tell you! Who would have thunk that hilldabeast would have foreign nationals making contributions to campaign.
Thanks. It must be my bitterness seeping out. Sorry, we’re only bitter when we zing Oh!b♥m♥. Clint♂n is fair game, right?
Good point BayState!
Now there’s the funny TT I so fondly remember…I laughed out loud a little on that one.
Seriously for a moment…Can we stop with all the foreign donations? Even for ex-Prez’s? Bill getting money from Saudi Arabia and Dubai is embrassing and unseemly. (I’m not talking parties here, I expect George will be getting a Saudi funded library too.)
Oooh! That was a good one, Tiger!
What ever happened to the Peter Paul scandal?
“Average” of $500.00/ticket?!? I didn’t realize Sir Elton commanded Barbra Streisand-type prices …………………..
Semper Fi’
DM
Michelle’s point is sound. The FEC is so impotent, there is no need holding our breath waiting for anything to happen. Even if all the nominations were approved and the vacancies filled, I wouldn’t hold out for any real action on it. Call me skeptical, I guess.
Nothing. Mary is not co-operating.
I don’t see a problem here if Mexico can set our immigration policy why can’t Great Britian select our presidential canidates?
Wrong title – should be Dame Elton John.
Unfortunately, nothing will come of this. The FEC is powerless so, as Barry says, ‘Don’t hold your breath.’
Why is Elton John, (not his real name-Reginald Dwight) referred to as “Sir” in this article. Here in America he isn’t a “Sir”, not that I’d call him “Lady” either.
How about Damn Elton John?
You guys are just fishing for the wrath of rusty.
Say, isn’t Sir Elton a extraterrestrial?
Can’t recall the planet, only that it’s described as flaming.
I have this image of fish and a barrel for some strange reason.
That’s a tempest in a teapot…sitting on a lacy doily!
Extra testicals! Sir indeed!
When I heard about this fundraiser, I questioned the propriety of a non-US citizen promoting a political figure. Seems to be a clear no-no according to what’s written above.
The only gray area could be if he holds dual citizenship.
MilwaukeeMike, Elton’s wife is an American. With 2 testicles. Does that change things at all?
When I saw this on TV I thought…”who the hell cares what Elton John thinks!” He is nothing but a chronic drug addict who neither lives here, nor is a citizen. He may have written some good songs, but who is he to tell me how to vote?
It would be like Bruce Sprinsteen (another liberal idiot) telling the people of England how to vote in their election. I would never be that presumptuous, but Liberals always are. That is one of the reasons they are so annoying.
MilwaukeeMike, he used to be a “dual citizen”, but now he’s only gay.
JohnS, Elton lives in Atlanta.
libocrat:
ROTFL. Well played.
It wouldn’t have even taken that long. The complaint would have been filed before the concert started.
I would never be that presumptuous, but Liberals always are. That is one of the reasons they are so annoying.
Riiiiggght. Just as presumptuous as your blanket statement.
Oh, credit JohnS for the above quote.
LOL Texas Tiger #24. I think Barack kidnapped Puff the magic dragon so Mary is out trying to find him.
Michelle, I need to learn how to read better or something….
John:
Thank you. Have some Barackware.
You are on a roll today Texas Tiger. Keep it up.
Hopefully no missile or satellite technology was exchanged for the services of a foreign national along with his political endorsement provided to “she who must not be named.” Even if the FEC could form a quorum I seriously doubt they would go after her.
Boomer?? “she who must not be named”??
Elton or Hillary?
Just confirms the relationship and the proper title – Dame Elton.
Coincidence or conspiracy? Hmm…
Don’t worry. When the heavens part, the choirs of angels sing and Oh!b♥m♥ is annointed, you too will be entitled to attend the
Derek ZoolanderBarack Obama Center For Children Who Can’t Read Good And Wanna Learn To Do Other Stuff Good Too. There you will learn that there’s more to life than being really, really good looking.You can’t blame the FEC. Who in their right mind would want to touch Elton John’s subpoena. Yeccch.
Tiger, you certainly are feeling your oats today, huh?
Nothing about the Clintons is coincidence. No doubt the reason the Democrats have blocked nominees to the FEC is to prevent any investigation into the upcoming election. Seems I read someplace a while back that there aren’t enough sitting members to make a quorum, hence nothing can or will be done until the next President is inaugurated. Go to your corners and come out cheating!
Yep, I want this investigated… and also Obamas campaign…
Seems that a LOT of campaign contributions are coming across the internet, and they’ve spoken of millions of dollars in contributions of $50 or $100… Problem is that anything less than 200 does not need to be declared to the FEC…
Is there anyone minding the store?
libocrat thanks for a great after dinner laugh! Great for the digestion! That’s the little pet name the wife and I have for Hillary. She is a huge Harry Potter fan. She is reading the “Deathly Hallows” again as I type this.
On April 14th, 2008 at 5:34 pm, DiamondMair said:
“Average” of $500.00/ticket?!? I didn’t realize Sir Elton commanded Barbra Streisand-type prices …………………..
Semper Fi’
DM
Why not? Both girls are plug ugly fiberal women, so it follows a pattern.
Aren’t we blessed to have MM?
Libocrat…you know what I mean. So he “lives” in Atlalnta. If you were to look I’d bet you he spends much of her (I mean his? whatever he/she is…)time in England. Even so it doesn’t matter. He is not a citizen so who cares what he thinks. I know I don’t and most of America doesn’t.
On another note, FNC online asks “Does Obama win if the world votes?” The world don’t get to vote. We do. So get over it. And if foreign countries want to play in our system then we should keep the money and jail the recipient.
Two of the world’s most repulsive people in the same picture! Ugh, I think I need a grief counselor, or an exorcist.
Um, yeah. I was thinking the same thing. I mean, why enforce one law when so many others are looked at as just plain breakable.
This thing has so embittered me, that I as a typical white rustic must hug my rifle, go to a prayer meeting, and drive my pickup around to yell at people who are different from me. Never has such a large group of people like Elton had so little to feel elite about.
“It’s sad, so sad. It’s a sad, sad situation. / But it’s getting more and more absurd. / It’s sad, so sad. Why can’t we talk it over. / Sorry seems to be the hardest word…”
Actually, last I checked (like when I worked for his label 89-94), Elton maintained a residence in Atlanta and (I thought) held dual citizenship. I could be wrong about the latter part.
Nonetheless, it’s unfortunate this should come up as Hil strives for her Philadelphia Freedom.
Besides the DOD which dept. is semi-functional anymore?
Seems to me that his statement about “women-hating Americans” is a little over the top considering his choice of a mate.
Valid points on the contributions of foreigners. Laws are laws, and no one should be above the law, not even George W Bush.
Question: Who (President) or what (Congress) is responsible for staffing the FEC? Why are these long standing vacancies being neglected? Who gains from this negligence? I’m not implying conspiracy, just trying to understand why, with so much electoral controversy in recent years, the FEC is left unstaffed.
Does anyone in government do their job any more?
Strange. It seems that she-who-should-not-be-named is a woman(?) that Sir(?) Elton doesn’t mind kissing. EEEEWWWWWW!
Gads!!!
This is why most (all?) campaign contribution limits should go.
How do you calculate the contribution of “labor”? Who has the objectivity and all-seeing power to create the formula?