Andrew Sullivan jumps in on Palin’s grandma-gate rumor

By see-dubya  •  August 31, 2008 10:16 PM

Andrew Sullivan, who once gave me a “Malkin Award” for “excitably” asking questions about the Obama-Ayers connection, is chasing down the TRUE FACTS ABOUT TRIG PALIN like Alex Jones shambling after a 9-11 widow holding a chocolate cake.

Ace wrote me to suggest I “never link this {naughty word} again”, which is a request I’ll gladly accommodate. I don’t think I ever have linked him and I’m certainly not going to reward such a gauche display of Ted-Sampley-level rumormongering with a link, even in order to laugh at him.

Anyway: you know what this reminds me of? Those two nights in 2004 when both John Kerry and John Edwards made a point to bring up DICK CHENEY’S GAY DAUGHTER during their respective debates–a gratuitous, pointless, dank, greasy, creepy cheapshot that reveals the Left to lack class as well as discernment.


(Edwards smarminess at one minute in.)

I guess it’s different because Dick Cheney’s daughter actually was gay, whereas this is a bizarre fantasy. But in both cases: even if this were true, so what? And as I mentioned below, if it were true, it actually makes Palin look saintly in her devotion to family.

The calculated sneering at Dick Cheney’s kid blew up in the Dems’ face. While I don’t wish any more intrusion into the Palins’ family life, I kind of hope the unhinged Left–among whose ranks the oh-so-cultivated Sullivan is now comfortably perched–keep showing this angry, unhinged, bitter snarl to the American public as they indulge their first instinct: going after the candidate’s mentally challenged infant son and high-school aged daughter.

Boors and barbarians. Is there a decent core to the Left–or at least a politically savvy core to the Left–that is willing to take a stand for decency?

Well, thought I’d ask.

***

MORE:

A commenter at Ann Althouse’s blog tonight, emphasis mine:

“she has a down syndrome baby, we should vote for her” That is the line by the right. She made her baby part of her schtick.

fair game.

And from 2004:

[Kerry] merely brought up Mary Cheney as a lesbian, out of left field, in order to get her name and sexual orientation into an answer where no such citation was expected, called for, or remotely appropriate. His campaign manager let slip the truth when after the debate she told Fox News’s Chris Wallace that Mary Cheney was “fair game.”

________________

Update (MM): I guess the nutroots think this post from an airline passenger who got a picture with then-pregnant Gov. Palin in late April is a Dan Rather-like fabrication.
____________

{Post by See-Dubya. On my own time, of course, and on my own computer, as all of these are.}
Delightful cover image lifted and cropped from Jimmie at the Sundries Shack.

~ For the latest breaking news, be sure to join Michelle's e-mail list ~

See what others have said

Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.

Comments


  1. #101
    On September 1st, 2008 at 2:15 am, Tommygun said:

    On September 1st, 2008 at 1:22 am, Omu said:

    I think Mary Cheney was fair game. Afterall, Dick and George were horrific to the gay community and continue to do so. Yet as soon as anyone brings up that obvious hypocritical fact, the right is up in arms. It’s sort of like: “How dare you subject ME and MY FAMILY to my own party’s out-dated, cruel and unfair standards!”. Really, had Mary actually stood up and said that she outraged at her father’s anti-gay ways, I would have more respect for her.

    In any case, though I suspect this rumor to be true (DailyKos more or less proves it – if this were a court of law, Palin would have been convicted), I am entirely unsettled about this spreading. It’s simply unfair to Mrs. Palin.

    Umm, well… You’re an idiot. There is no hypocrisy between people holding a particular (and proper) view of morality, and then showing love and tolerance toward a family member who chooses to depart from that. I know stupid Leftist-socialists like yourself are totally incapable of understanding that INDIVIDUALS can make choices. They choose to hold to values, and their daughter chose to depart from them.

    The truth of idiots like you is that had the disowned her, you [CENSORED] would have cried out about, “Where are your family values? Just because Mary doesn’t conform to your image you disown her?”

    Hey! When McCain-Palin (hopefully) correct the Bush-Cheney mistake of not rounding you all up into camps where we can concentrate you, perhaps you will be Inmate #1.

    I would say more, but MM is too Left-wing to allow it.

    A little bit of reactionary hatred can be a good thing! (YES! Quote me on that!)

    Just a few thoughts. Thanks for reading.

  2. #102
    On September 1st, 2008 at 2:16 am, Lincoln said:

    Andrew Sullivan and those Kos-Cads are the most piggish, pig-like, pig-borking, piggered-up pigs to have ever graced the Internet.

  3. #103
    On September 1st, 2008 at 2:26 am, papertiger said:

    Dr. Hugh Jassman, the obgyn who performed the clandestine delivery, is on the phone with us now. Good evening Dr. Jassman.
    “Guden tag, Heir Obermann. Danka for havink me on der show.”
    Your welcome Dr. So you performed the back alley delivery on the Palin girl. Would you be willing to swear to that in the court of public oppinion?
    “Jah ien shwear it ober a stack of bibles.”
    Right, thanks. So there you have it folks. My name is Keith Olbermann, and I approve this message.

  4. #104
    On September 1st, 2008 at 2:38 am, Micheleeroo said:

    Rumor debunked. Said photo was taken in 2006. Palin gave birth in 2008. These goofballs at KOS are actually implying that a teenager was pregnant for two years. Or something like that. I can hardly believe any of the KOS people thought anyone was gullible enough to believe a lame story like that.

  5. #105
    On September 1st, 2008 at 2:38 am, RogerCfromSD said:

    If Sarah Palin is so inexperienced and not a credible threat to Obama, why the need for all the attacks on her and on her children?

    Liberals are like pit bulls. Shake their chain and they get all slobbery and barky and stuff. They should stick to licking their privates.

  6. #106
    On September 1st, 2008 at 2:53 am, Kokonut said:

    Who’s that guy screaming?

    Why it’s Dr. McCoy. Lovely teeth, btw. RIP DeForest Kelley.

    http://www.littlestuffedbull.com/images/comics/trekfotonovel/trekfotonovel-15.jpg

  7. #107
    On September 1st, 2008 at 3:02 am, RabbidSquirrel said:

    See? I gave you all a heads-up yesterday that I just play a conservative ‘character’ for MM and that I play a liberal activist over on Kos…. but you didnt listen.

    the Kos Kids are now trying to find out… What Rovian Conspirator tricked us into believing this story?

    And all of you are just bit players in my master plan!!!

    [Queue conspiritorial laugh]
    [fade to black]
    [roll credits]

  8. #108
    On September 1st, 2008 at 3:06 am, Politicalguano said:

    I am sick of subhuman liberals abusing conservative’s children -labeling children “fair game.” The POS that calls itself Andrew Sullivan, is still fixated and bitter that most people find the marriage of homosexuals repugnant and has since spent the rest of his career trying to hurt decent people. Sullivan apparently thinks that he is ethical and therefore is not bound by rules of decency as a reporter/journalist – but it is clear to me that he has become a bitter, child bashing lump of filth.

  9. #109
    On September 1st, 2008 at 3:08 am, dpwiener said:

    This boggles the mind. Hasn’t anybody ever heard of “DNA”? If Trig is Sarah’s child then half of their genes will match. If Trig is Sarah’s grandchild then only a quarter of their genes will match. Should the leftists continue to amp this up into a major controversy, a simple DNA test is all it would take to blow them out of the water. And the consequent PR backlash would result in a landslide Republican victory.

    It’s almost enough to make one believe that Rove is behind it all.

  10. #110
    On September 1st, 2008 at 3:32 am, mattymatt10 said:

    If Palin is so terribly inexperienced, and such a joke of a nominee, why is it necessary to slime her with stories like this?

    If she’s as incompetent as the left says, the she’ll be exposed as a buffoon on the campaign trail, and this gutter trash isn’t necessary.

    They’re scared. And they should be.

  11. #111
    On September 1st, 2008 at 4:00 am, txvet2 said:

    omu and nero, don’t you pay any attention at all to these people asking you to stop posting and go away. We need you and lgm here every day to remind people who might otherwise forget just how stupid, biased and intolerant the nutcase left really is in this country.

  12. #112
    On September 1st, 2008 at 4:04 am, tonyr951 said:
  13. #113
    On September 1st, 2008 at 4:13 am, AlohaGuy said:

    It’s simply unfair to Mrs. Palin.

    And her daughter, and her son…

  14. #114
    On September 1st, 2008 at 5:55 am, graysonret said:

    Remember, liberal politics are based on “feelings”. They “feel”, rather than, “think”. So, instead of defending principles logically, they have to resort to “emotional stories” in order to compete in the campaigns. It works for many people though. They will vote for Obama because it “feels good” rather than looking at his ideas for a new marxist government.

  15. #115
    On September 1st, 2008 at 6:14 am, ajmontana said:

    Emu,
    If this were a Court of Law:

    He would be proven a Muslim
    Proven he has Terrorist ties
    Proven he is more God Damn America than God Bless America.
    Proven his wife hates America.
    Proven he has H.I.V. virus.
    Proven he is NOT his Brothers keeper.
    Proven he is Impotent.
    Proven Michelle’s kids are NOT his.
    Proven you are a complete and utter toolbag moron.

  16. #116
    On September 1st, 2008 at 6:21 am, ajmontana said:

    The trolls, Dems and Libs have their bloomers in a bunch.
    and it’s killin em
    I Love It!

  17. #117
    On September 1st, 2008 at 7:14 am, jcjimi said:

    OK, I used to read Sullivan back in the day and I’m dying to know…

    What happened?

    The guy has gone completely insane. Seriously. He’s losing his mind in front of a public audience. At this rate I’m expecting him to shave his head and attack an SUV with an umbrella any minute now.

  18. #118
    On September 1st, 2008 at 7:15 am, Uplander said:

    omu?

    (DailyKos more or less proves it – if this were a court of law, Palin would have been convicted)?????????????

    DailyKos hasn’t the resources or the intellect to prove they can blow their nose.
    If you are going to source a post, use a credible source, please.

  19. #119
    On September 1st, 2008 at 7:30 am, purplepeep said:

    jcjimi said:
    OK, I used to read Sullivan back in the day and I’m dying to know…

    What happened?

    The guy has gone completely insane. Seriously. He’s losing his mind in front of a public audience. At this rate I’m expecting him to shave his head and attack an SUV with an umbrella any minute now.

    I used to look at his stuff in the past, too, jimi. Now, only when somebody cites a specific post of his.

    Some have speculated it might be caused by AIDS-related dementia. I don’t know how far HIV-AIDS has run it’s course with him, but that’s one explanation I’ve seen pop up now and then.

    Or he could have gone just totally nuts completely apart from any illness or disease. Insanity happens.

  20. #120
    On September 1st, 2008 at 7:35 am, purplepeep said:

    Uplander said:
    If you are going to source a post, use a credible source, please.

    What? You don’t believe everything you read at the Kos Kidz Playhouse, Uplander???? I’m shocked!!

  21. #121
    On September 1st, 2008 at 7:53 am, zorro said:

    Update (MM): I guess the nutroots think this post from an airline passenger who got a picture with then-pregnant Gov. Palin in late April is a Dan Rather-like fabrication.

    Case closed.

  22. #122
    On September 1st, 2008 at 8:48 am, misterbee241 said:

    Boors and barbarians. Is there a decent core to the Left–or at least a politically savvy core to the Left–that is willing to take a stand for decency?

    In a word – No. In my lifetime I’ve watched the Democrat party go from the party of the working man (I heard that when I was a kid) to the party of Marx and Lenin. They are the old Communist Party wrapped up in “hope and change” and they are pretty blatent about it. They are no longer for the working men and women (if they ever were) but are for increased government control over people, production and property. that’s socialism. And they’ll do it all within the frame work of the Constitution. There are enough activist judges to make it so.
    The Leftist Democrats can and will use every lie and smear they can come up with because it’s in the Socialist/Marxist playbook. All the old-line Commies, Stalin, Mao all of them endorsed and encouraged the very tactics the democrat party is using right now. The goal is to win at any price. The ends always justify the means.
    Do you wonder why the CPUSA endorses every Democrat candidate? Because they are fellow travellers.
    If Obama and the Democrats win in November we will no longer be a free republic but a socialist republic.

  23. #123
    On September 1st, 2008 at 8:49 am, Ulthwithian said:

    I must say, Liberal rhetoric leaves much to be desired in terms of actual logos. As someone here said, their entire rhetorical method revolves around pathos.

    It’s useful for swaying hearts, but not for swaying the mind.

  24. #124
    On September 1st, 2008 at 9:18 am, NY Andy said:

    Democrats are always claiming that republicans can’t identify with the great unwashed.

    Here is a republican governor who sells her state jet when elected and now flies commercially. She called the private jet impractical in the page linked to. You’ve got to love such common sense and concern for the state finances.

    You would think that democrats would be ecstatic, that’s more money for hooking voters up to the state teat and killing babies!

  25. #125
    On September 1st, 2008 at 9:57 am, travlinman said:

    Well my sister-in-laws’ next door neighbor’s cousins’ brothers’ ex-wife’s uncle’s girl-friend’s dad had an old army buddy who overheard someone at the liquor store talking about their neice’s fiance’s mother’s aunt’s paperboy’s older sister went to pre-school with the Palin girl and she said that the baby was hers.

  26. #126
    On September 1st, 2008 at 10:08 am, MacEamonn said:

    On August 31st, 2008 at 10:25 pm, see-dubya said:
    Sure, Athena, that’s just what they want you to believe. That could easily be a pillow under there.

    Hey, if they–you know, them– could rig WTC-7 with demolition charges without anyone noticing, faking a pregnancy would be no trouble at all!

    see-dubya forgot to mention that George Bush and Dick Cheney personally set the charges that knocked out the levies in NO during Katrina. The MSM should be watching them both very closely because they’re probably going to do it again during Gustav! ;)

  27. #127
    On September 1st, 2008 at 10:08 am, travlinman said:

    On September 1st, 2008 at 6:14 am, ajmontana said:
    Emu,
    If this were a Court of Law:
    He would be proven a Muslim
    Proven he has Terrorist ties
    Proven he is more God Damn America than God Bless America.
    Proven his wife hates America.
    Proven he has H.I.V. virus.
    Proven he is NOT his Brothers keeper.
    Proven he is Impotent.
    Proven Michelle’s kids are NOT his.
    Proven you are a complete and utter toolbag moron.

    AJ, you forgot to mention “proof” of Obama using cocaine and having Bill Clint-type sex with a Male prostitute. Funny how none of us thought that story to have any credibility, yet the left will jump on anything they perceive as having the ability of erasing one vote for McCain/Palin. Dems are scared. They should change his name to Brrrrraaaaaaack (chicken cluck) Obama.

  28. #128
    On September 1st, 2008 at 10:09 am, Blackwatch said:

    Until the U.S. people start calling a ‘spade as a spade’, i.e. that Liberals are in fact Marxist Communists, and the DNC kicks them out of the DNC FOREVER, then we all will continue to hear and be ‘shocked’ at what ‘Liberals’ do and say.

    Liberals are NOT Democrats, they are Marxist Communists and a enemy to everything the Constitution stands for…they only use the Constitution to gain power and to subjugate the U.S.

  29. #129
    On September 1st, 2008 at 10:14 am, travlinman said:

    Well my sister-in-laws’ next door neighbor’s cousins’ brothers’ ex-wife’s uncle’s girl-friend’s dad had an old army buddy who overheard someone at the liquor store talking about their neice’s fiance’s mother’s aunt’s paperboy’s older sister, who had a friend living in NOLA during Katrina and she saw Bush and Cheney rigging the levees and watched them push the trigger on the detonator.

  30. #130
    On September 1st, 2008 at 11:05 am, ArizonaNeanderthal said:

    And when some Left Wing activist tries to sell you Tonic Water about a Civil Debate you throw this story right in their face. When that Tonic Water is “using Hussein is causing fear” you tell them -you are right, and we do. We fear and hate you.

    travlinman too bad that story can’t be a funny as it deserves; these wackos do start to believe their own lies.

    Hey Obama-What to see Bitter?
    Look at your wife.

    WE SHOULD BE CIVIL-WE CONSERVATIVES?
    Not a chance.

  31. #131
    On September 1st, 2008 at 12:29 pm, papertiger said:

    Folks lets target the guilty. The DKers are stupid and gullible – that’s not a crime though. They were misled by the Anchorage Daily News. Here is the Wikipage for ADN.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchorage_Daily_News
    It says, “The McClatchy Company has owned the Daily News since 1979, when it bought a controlling interest from Kay Fanning, who had been editor and publisher since the death of her husband, Larry Fanning, in 1971. Kay Fanning continued as the head of the paper until mid-1983.
    The McClatchy Company authored this smear of Sarah Palin over this last year.
    They birthed it, they nurtured it, the only thing they didn’t do is take ownership of it. Instead they sent out snipers – using the Anchorage Daily News as cover.

    You check, those rumors that the Dkers and Sully ran with, all originated with ADN – hence McClatchy.

  32. #132
    On September 1st, 2008 at 12:38 pm, DianeK said:

    Have you noticed that when the rumors first started the daughter was out of school for two months, it is now up to six months (I saw one comment saying eight months)

  33. #133
    On September 1st, 2008 at 3:08 pm, Chief RZ said:

    These people remind me of some of the low class people who asked my wife if our child was mine. This actually happened. What they reveal is their own lack of morality and decent living. I taught the general population, that is, all of the students in that school district. Things got very bad at one point when about 95% of the students were “on something” when they arrived at school. I wonder how many of the democrats are “on something.”

  34. #134
    On September 1st, 2008 at 5:12 pm, vickisoup said:

    My friend sent me the Kos link accidentally, and then apologized for “offending me”.
    I told her the only thing that offended me was that she sent it to anyone at all, because it made her look irrational & small, neither of which I would have ascribed to her previously.
    Oh…and this friend had all the sex ed anyone could get and she still ended up pregnant, unexpectedly. Guess the left’s latest volley is as stupid as the first. :roll:

  35. #135
    On September 1st, 2008 at 5:39 pm, TXRose said:

    Wizbangblog.com Before Liberals Dismiss Governor Palin’s Experience as
    Commander in Chief of Alaska’s National Guard

    This is a great article that says that since Alaska’s National Guard is so vital to the
    security of this country, Sarah Palin IS more experienced than Nobama and may even
    have security clearances we have never heard of.

    (My links to Wizbang don’t always seem to work, that’s why I didn’t put up a link)

  36. #136
    On September 1st, 2008 at 5:40 pm, TXRose said:

    That shouldn’t be run together…I have a little dog on
    my lap. It’s wizbangblog.com and then the name of
    the article .

  37. #137
    On September 1st, 2008 at 11:50 pm, lonewolf said:

    The only difference in Bristol Palin and a huge percentage of her classmates is she got pregnant…. and is having the baby instead of an abortion.

  38. #138
    On September 2nd, 2008 at 8:57 am, tamarah180 said:

    You know…if ANYONE should denounce this should be Michelle Obama, since she’s so concerned about children and said “this doesn’t help my children” in some speech not too long ago. Well, you know what Michelle? This really doesn’t help Sarah Palin’s 17 year old daughter either.

    Uh, MO only protects little black children and white kids of Dems. Bristol is neither. Fair game and doesn’t affect HER kids.

    BTW when I was preg with my eldest (yeah, I was teen who got preg without the benefit of marriage, fought my mother for 5 months TO NOT HAVE AN ABORTION) and was assigned a hospital 3 hours away by car and had to make the trip in a blizzard AFTER MY WATER BROKE.

    He is now 28 and the father of my 7 grandchildren.

    And he is a Republican who could hardly contain himself when McCain announced his very amazing running mate. My DIL is registering to vote this year, too.

  39. #139
    On September 2nd, 2008 at 9:46 am, GraniteMan said:

    Why do Dem’s believe that a President who molests a 21 year old intern in the oval office is not newsworthy and is his private business get all bent out of shape over a 17 year old kid getting pregnant? What I find refreshing is the young man facing his responsiblity in this and being a man. God bless the Palins and

    GO SARAH!

  40. #140
    On September 23rd, 2008 at 6:31 pm, theporch said:

    RogercfSD— That was really funny and right on. Especially the private parts thing. They are out to destroy a perfect nice human being and doing anything they can to accomplish their goal. On the kos site they brag about creating lies and repeating them until the MSM picks them up and does their bidding and carries the ball for them.

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Choosing Life and Beating the Odds

February 11, 2012 11:50 AM by Doug Powers

32 Comments

‘To Stop the Multiplication of the Unfit’

February 10, 2012 09:06 AM by Michelle Malkin

199 Comments

First, they came for the Catholics

January 31, 2012 10:51 PM by Michelle Malkin

181 Comments

The March for Life 2012

January 23, 2012 10:21 AM by Michelle Malkin

132 Comments

First Day of 2012 Open Thread & Aspirin-Swapping Roundtable

January 1, 2012 11:45 AM by Doug Powers

235 Comments

Happy new year!

Reports: Miners trapped in Mullan, Idaho; 6 hospitalized

December 15, 2011 01:34 AM by Michelle Malkin

23 Comments

Pinheads at Penn State

November 10, 2011 02:50 AM by Michelle Malkin

186 Comments


Categories: Abortion,Andrew Sullivan,Uncategorized

Redstate

» Media Matters
Follow me on Twitter Follow me on Facebook