Breaking: It’s official. House rejects Trillion-Dollar-Plus Crap Sandwich; roll call vote added
Scroll for updates…roll call vote added…
The votes have been tallied.
228 NAY.
205 YEA.
The Crap Sandwich goes down in flames. (My liveblog of the floor debate is here.)
Still no official announcement on the House floor. Lots of yelling for “order.”
Someone has changed his/her vote.
It’s now 227 NAY, 206 YEA, 1 Not Voting.
1:59pm Eastern. The allotted 15 minutes for voting is over, but there is still no official announcement. Arm-twisting is underway, but only one changed vote so far.
2:06pm Eastern. It’s official. The MOAB has failed.
Yeah, a lot of Chicken Littles are running around screaming about the Dow dropping.
It’s dropped less than 5 percent.
Apocalyptics said it would be down 20-30 percent.
The bailout failed.
The world survives.
***
2:29pm Eastern. I’ve been trying to access the House website for the roll call vote, but the entire site is hung up.
Meantime, the GOP leadership is holding a press conference. Imagine if they had been on the right side of this monster. They could be claiming victory, seizing the momentum, and advancing the conservative agenda. Instead, they’re complaining about Nancy Pelosi’s partisan attack on the floor. (Vid here.) What did you expect, crap sandwich swallowers?
***
Here’s the roll call vote…
H R 3997 RECORDED VOTE 29-Sep-2008 2:07 PM
AYES
Democratic 140
Republican 65
NOES
Democrat 95
Republican 133
NOT VOTING
Republican 1
TOTALS
AYES 205
NOES 228
QUESTION: On Concurring in Senate Amendment With An Amendment
BILL TITLE: To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide earnings assistance and tax relief to members of the uniformed services, volunteer firefighters, and Peace Corps volunteers, and for other purposes
Ackerman D NY legislator Aye
Allen D ME legislator Aye
Andrews D NJ legislator Aye
Arcuri D NY legislator Aye
Baird D WA legislator Aye
Baldwin D WI legislator Aye
Bean D IL legislator Aye
Berman D CA legislator Aye
Berry D AR legislator Aye
Bishop (GA) D GA legislator Aye
Bishop (NY) D NY legislator Aye
Boren D OK legislator Aye
Boswell D IA legislator Aye
Boucher D VA legislator Aye
Boyd (FL) D FL legislator Aye
Brady (PA) D PA legislator Aye
Brown, Corrine D FL legislator Aye
Capps D CA legislator Aye
Capuano D MA legislator Aye
Cardoza D CA legislator Aye
Carnahan D MO legislator Aye
Clarke D NY legislator Aye
Clyburn D SC legislator Aye
Cohen D TN legislator Aye
Cooper D TN legislator Aye
Costa D CA legislator Aye
Cramer D AL legislator Aye
Crowley D NY legislator Aye
Davis (AL) D AL legislator Aye
Davis (CA) D CA legislator Aye
Davis (IL) D IL legislator Aye
DeGette D CO legislator Aye
DeLauro D CT legislator Aye
Dicks D WA legislator Aye
Dingell D MI legislator Aye
Donnelly D IN legislator Aye
Doyle D PA legislator Aye
Edwards (TX) D TX legislator Aye
Ellison D MN legislator Aye
Ellsworth D IN legislator Aye
Emanuel D IL legislator Aye
Engel D NY legislator Aye
Eshoo D CA legislator Aye
Etheridge D NC legislator Aye
Farr D CA legislator Aye
Fattah D PA legislator Aye
Foster D IL legislator Aye
Frank (MA) D MA legislator Aye
Gonzalez D TX legislator Aye
Gordon D TN legislator Aye
Gutierrez D IL legislator Aye
Hall (NY) D NY legislator Aye
Hare D IL legislator Aye
Harman D CA legislator Aye
Hastings (FL) D FL legislator Aye
Higgins D NY legislator Aye
Hinojosa D TX legislator Aye
Holt D NJ legislator Aye
Honda D CA legislator Aye
Hooley D OR legislator Aye
Hoyer D MD legislator Aye
Israel D NY legislator Aye
Johnson, E. B. D TX legislator Aye
Kanjorski D PA legislator Aye
Kennedy D RI legislator Aye
Kildee D MI legislator Aye
Kind D WI legislator Aye
Klein (FL) D FL legislator Aye
Langevin D RI legislator Aye
Larsen (WA) D WA legislator Aye
Larson (CT) D CT legislator Aye
Levin D MI legislator Aye
Loebsack D IA legislator Aye
Lofgren, Zoe D CA legislator Aye
Lowey D NY legislator Aye
Mahoney (FL) D FL legislator Aye
Maloney (NY) D NY legislator Aye
Markey D MA legislator Aye
Marshall D GA legislator Aye
Matsui D CA legislator Aye
McCarthy (NY) D NY legislator Aye
McCollum (MN) D MN legislator Aye
McDermott D WA legislator Aye
McGovern D MA legislator Aye
McNerney D CA legislator Aye
McNulty D NY legislator Aye
Meek (FL) D FL legislator Aye
Meeks (NY) D NY legislator Aye
Melancon D LA legislator Aye
Miller (NC) D NC legislator Aye
Miller, George D CA legislator Aye
Mollohan D WV legislator Aye
Moore (KS) D KS legislator Aye
Moore (WI) D WI legislator Aye
Moran (VA) D VA legislator Aye
Murphy (CT) D CT legislator Aye
Murphy, Patrick D PA legislator Aye
Murtha D PA legislator Aye
Nadler D NY legislator Aye
Neal (MA) D MA legislator Aye
Oberstar D MN legislator Aye
Obey D WI legislator Aye
Olver D MA legislator Aye
Pallone D NJ legislator Aye
Pelosi D CA speaker Aye
Perlmutter D CO legislator Aye
Pomeroy D ND legislator Aye
Price (NC) D NC legislator Aye
Rahall D WV legislator Aye
Rangel D NY legislator Aye
Reyes D TX legislator Aye
Richardson D CA legislator Aye
Ross D AR legislator Aye
Ruppersberger D MD legislator Aye
Ryan (OH) D OH legislator Aye
Sarbanes D MD legislator Aye
Schakowsky D IL legislator Aye
Schwartz D PA legislator Aye
Sestak D PA legislator Aye
Sires D NJ legislator Aye
Skelton D MO legislator Aye
Slaughter D NY legislator Aye
Smith (WA) D WA legislator Aye
Snyder D AR legislator Aye
Space D OH legislator Aye
Speier D CA legislator Aye
Spratt D SC legislator Aye
Tanner D TN legislator Aye
Tauscher D CA legislator Aye
Towns D NY legislator Aye
Tsongas D MA legislator Aye
Van Hollen D MD legislator Aye
Velazquez D NY legislator Aye
Wasserman Schultz D FL legislator Aye
Waters D CA legislator Aye
Watt D NC legislator Aye
Waxman D CA legislator Aye
Weiner D NY legislator Aye
Wexler D FL legislator Aye
Wilson (OH) D OH legislator Aye
Bachus R AL legislator Aye
Blunt R MO legislator Aye
Boehner R OH legislator Aye
Bonner R AL legislator Aye
Bono Mack R CA legislator Aye
Boozman R AR legislator Aye
Brady (TX) R TX legislator Aye
Brown (SC) R SC legislator Aye
Calvert R CA legislator Aye
Camp (MI) R MI legislator Aye
Campbell (CA) R CA legislator Aye
Cannon R UT legislator Aye
Cantor R VA legislator Aye
Castle R DE legislator Aye
Cole (OK) R OK legislator Aye
Crenshaw R FL legislator Aye
Cubin R WY legislator Aye
Davis, Tom R VA legislator Aye
Dreier R CA legislator Aye
Ehlers R MI legislator Aye
Emerson R MO legislator Aye
Everett R AL legislator Aye
Ferguson R NJ legislator Aye
Fossella R NY legislator Aye
Gilchrest R MD legislator Aye
Granger R TX legislator Aye
Herger R CA legislator Aye
Hobson R OH legislator Aye
Inglis (SC) R SC legislator Aye
King (NY) R NY legislator Aye
Kirk R IL legislator Aye
Kline (MN) R MN legislator Aye
LaHood R IL legislator Aye
Lewis (CA) R CA legislator Aye
Lewis (KY) R KY legislator Aye
Lungren, Daniel E. R CA legislator Aye
McCrery R LA legislator Aye
McHugh R NY legislator Aye
McKeon R CA legislator Aye
Miller, Gary R CA legislator Aye
Peterson (PA) R PA legislator Aye
Pickering R MS legislator Aye
Porter R NV legislator Aye
Pryce (OH) R OH legislator Aye
Putnam R FL legislator Aye
Radanovich R CA legislator Aye
Regula R OH legislator Aye
Reynolds R NY legislator Aye
Rogers (AL) R AL legislator Aye
Rogers (KY) R KY legislator Aye
Ryan (WI) R WI legislator Aye
Saxton R NJ legislator Aye
Sessions R TX legislator Aye
Shays R CT legislator Aye
Simpson R ID legislator Aye
Smith (TX) R TX legislator Aye
Souder R IN legislator Aye
Tancredo R CO legislator Aye
Upton R MI legislator Aye
Walden (OR) R OR legislator Aye
Walsh (NY) R NY legislator Aye
Weldon (FL) R FL legislator Aye
Wilson (NM) R NM legislator Aye
Wilson (SC) R SC legislator Aye
Wolf R VA legislator Aye
Abercrombie D HI legislator No
Altmire D PA legislator No
Baca D CA legislator No
Barrow D GA legislator No
Becerra D CA legislator No
Berkley D NV legislator No
Blumenauer D OR legislator No
Boyda (KS) D KS legislator No
Braley (IA) D IA legislator No
Butterfield D NC legislator No
Carney D PA legislator No
Carson D IN legislator No
Castor D FL legislator No
Cazayoux D LA legislator No
Chandler D KY legislator No
Childers D MS legislator No
Clay D MO legislator No
Cleaver D MO legislator No
Conyers D MI legislator No
Costello D IL legislator No
Courtney D CT legislator No
Cuellar D TX legislator No
Cummings D MD legislator No
Davis, Lincoln D TN legislator No
DeFazio D OR legislator No
Delahunt D MA legislator No
Doggett D TX legislator No
Edwards (MD) D MD legislator No
Filner D CA legislator No
Giffords D AZ legislator No
Gillibrand D NY legislator No
Green, Al D TX legislator No
Green, Gene D TX legislator No
Grijalva D AZ legislator No
Herseth Sandlin D SD legislator No
Hill D IN legislator No
Hinchey D NY legislator No
Hirono D HI legislator No
Hodes D NH legislator No
Holden D PA legislator No
Inslee D WA legislator No
Jackson (IL) D IL legislator No
Jackson-Lee (TX) D TX legislator No
Jefferson D LA legislator No
Johnson (GA) D GA legislator No
Kagen D WI legislator No
Kaptur D OH legislator No
Kilpatrick D MI legislator No
Kucinich D OH legislator No
Lampson D TX legislator No
Lee D CA legislator No
Lewis (GA) D GA legislator No
Lipinski D IL legislator No
Lynch D MA legislator No
Matheson D UT legislator No
McIntyre D NC legislator No
Michaud D ME legislator No
Mitchell D AZ legislator No
Napolitano D CA legislator No
Ortiz D TX legislator No
Pascrell D NJ legislator No
Pastor D AZ legislator No
Payne D NJ legislator No
Peterson (MN) D MN legislator No
Rodriguez D TX legislator No
Rothman D NJ legislator No
Roybal-Allard D CA legislator No
Rush D IL legislator No
Salazar D CO legislator No
Sanchez, Linda T. D CA legislator No
Sanchez, Loretta D CA legislator No
Schiff D CA legislator No
Scott (GA) D GA legislator No
Scott (VA) D VA legislator No
Serrano D NY legislator No
Shea-Porter D NH legislator No
Sherman D CA legislator No
Shuler D NC legislator No
Solis D CA legislator No
Stark D CA legislator No
Stupak D MI legislator No
Sutton D OH legislator No
Taylor D MS legislator No
Thompson (CA) D CA legislator No
Thompson (MS) D MS legislator No
Tierney D MA legislator No
Udall (CO) D CO legislator No
Udall (NM) D NM legislator No
Visclosky D IN legislator No
Walz (MN) D MN legislator No
Watson D CA legislator No
Welch (VT) D VT legislator No
Woolsey D CA legislator No
Wu D OR legislator No
Yarmuth D KY legislator No
Aderholt R AL legislator No
Akin R MO legislator No
Alexander R LA legislator No
Bachmann R MN legislator No
Barrett (SC) R SC legislator No
Bartlett (MD) R MD legislator No
Barton (TX) R TX legislator No
Biggert R IL legislator No
Bilbray R CA legislator No
Bilirakis R FL legislator No
Bishop (UT) R UT legislator No
Blackburn R TN legislator No
Boustany R LA legislator No
Broun (GA) R GA legislator No
Brown-Waite, Ginny R FL legislator No
Buchanan R FL legislator No
Burgess R TX legislator No
Burton (IN) R IN legislator No
Buyer R IN legislator No
Capito R WV legislator No
Carter R TX legislator No
Chabot R OH legislator No
Coble R NC legislator No
Conaway R TX legislator No
Culberson R TX legislator No
Davis (KY) R KY legislator No
Davis, David R TN legislator No
Deal (GA) R GA legislator No
Dent R PA legislator No
Diaz-Balart, L. R FL legislator No
Diaz-Balart, M. R FL legislator No
Doolittle R CA legislator No
Drake R VA legislator No
Duncan R TN legislator No
English (PA) R PA legislator No
Fallin R OK legislator No
Feeney R FL legislator No
Flake R AZ legislator No
Forbes R VA legislator No
Fortenberry R NE legislator No
Foxx R NC legislator No
Franks (AZ) R AZ legislator No
Frelinghuysen R NJ legislator No
Gallegly R CA legislator No
Garrett (NJ) R NJ legislator No
Gerlach R PA legislator No
Gingrey R GA legislator No
Gohmert R TX legislator No
Goode R VA legislator No
Goodlatte R VA legislator No
Graves R MO legislator No
Hall (TX) R TX legislator No
Hastings (WA) R WA legislator No
Hayes R NC legislator No
Heller R NV legislator No
Hensarling R TX legislator No
Hoekstra R MI legislator No
Hulshof R MO legislator No
Hunter R CA legislator No
Issa R CA legislator No
Johnson (IL) R IL legislator No
Johnson, Sam R TX legislator No
Jones (NC) R NC legislator No
Jordan R OH legislator No
Keller R FL legislator No
King (IA) R IA legislator No
Kingston R GA legislator No
Knollenberg R MI legislator No
Kuhl (NY) R NY legislator No
Lamborn R CO legislator No
Latham R IA legislator No
LaTourette R OH legislator No
Latta R OH legislator No
Linder R GA legislator No
LoBiondo R NJ legislator No
Lucas R OK legislator No
Mack R FL legislator No
Manzullo R IL legislator No
Marchant R TX legislator No
McCarthy (CA) R CA legislator No
McCaul (TX) R TX legislator No
McCotter R MI legislator No
McHenry R NC legislator No
McMorris Rodgers R WA legislator No
Mica R FL legislator No
Miller (FL) R FL legislator No
Miller (MI) R MI legislator No
Moran (KS) R KS legislator No
Murphy, Tim R PA legislator No
Musgrave R CO legislator No
Myrick R NC legislator No
Neugebauer R TX legislator No
Nunes R CA legislator No
Paul R TX legislator No
Pearce R NM legislator No
Pence R IN legislator No
Petri R WI legislator No
Pitts R PA legislator No
Platts R PA legislator No
Poe R TX legislator No
Price (GA) R GA legislator No
Ramstad R MN legislator No
Rehberg R MT legislator No
Reichert R WA legislator No
Renzi R AZ legislator No
Rogers (MI) R MI legislator No
Rohrabacher R CA legislator No
Ros-Lehtinen R FL legislator No
Roskam R IL legislator No
Royce R CA legislator No
Sali R ID legislator No
Scalise R LA legislator No
Schmidt R OH legislator No
Sensenbrenner R WI legislator No
Shadegg R AZ legislator No
Shimkus R IL legislator No
Shuster R PA legislator No
Smith (NE) R NE legislator No
Smith (NJ) R NJ legislator No
Stearns R FL legislator No
Sullivan R OK legislator No
Terry R NE legislator No
Thornberry R TX legislator No
Tiahrt R KS legislator No
Tiberi R OH legislator No
Turner R OH legislator No
Walberg R MI legislator No
Wamp R TN legislator No
Westmoreland R GA legislator No
Whitfield (KY) R KY legislator No
Wittman (VA) R VA legislator No
Young (AK) R AK legislator No
Young (FL) R FL legislator No
Weller R IL legislator Not Voting
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Trackbacks
- Michelle Malkin » Kill the bailout: The House floor debate is on; Bill fails
- silent E speaks - Conservatively Speaking from Western Waukesha County » MOAB Update: Thanks But NO!!!
- Ogre’s Politics and Views » Bailout FAILS!
- Should House Republicans just vote NO on bail out? (UPDATE: Video) « Sharp Right Turn
- BREAKING: House Rejects , An Ol’ Broad’s Ramblings
- The American People Want A Full Meal Buffett Deal–Not A Bailout! « Pronk Palisades
- southchild » Blog Archive » House Republicans to the Rescue
- Bloodthirsty Liberal » Hey, Nancy Palooza—Who’s Unpatriotic Now?
- BAILOUT FAILS! « Down the Ticket
- BipolarNation.com » Let the Storm Pass
- Bailout Dies on the Vine | NeoConstant
- Video Done Right
- Nicholas Fitzgerald » Pelosi’s Mouth Kills Bail Out Plan
- Webloggin » Bailout Bill Rejected: 40% Dems and 67% Repubs Vote No
- And it fails! Bloggers react. « Politics and Profits: Business and the 2008 Election
- Plumb Bob Blog » Doesn’t Matter How Good the Bailout Plan Was
- WeatherOutpost12
- Oops: Shit Sandwich Fails « Nice Deb
- Bailing Out The Bush Legacy: Wither Conservatism? | Political Vindication
- The Other McCain: Bipartisan bailout blowup!
- Text of Bailout Bill: Read The Latest Draft « Sooshi Soo
- Right Angles » Blog Archive » NC delegation votes 9-4 against ‘crap sandwich’ bailout bill
- Mark Levin Fan » Blog Archive » 95 House Democrats join 133 Republicans to defeat bailout
- House Defeats Bailout Bill - What Now? | FullosseousFlap's Dental Blog
- Take That Bill And Shove It! | Democrat=Socialist
- Seymour Nuts » Blog Archive » Thank God This Bailout Died
- Democrats Kill Bailout | Faith and Facts
- Obama’s “Economic Justice” Equals Socialism : Ft. Hard Knox
- Jules Crittenden » Sky, Falling
- House Rejects Bailout Package, Stocks Plunge « Musings of a Thoughtful Conservative
- Pelosi Craps On Republicans = Bailout Bill Goes To The Crapper | BigMouthFrog
- Cassy Fiano » Blogosphere round-up on the bailout
- Scroll For Updates: Breaking:Bailout bill fails…Bitchlosi’s Words That Sealed Its Fate..Republicans Blames Bitchlosi, The Market Loses $1.1 Trillion In Value, She May Add ACORN Back In | Right Voices
- Pelosi drives America off the cliff! « Riggword Weblog
- University Blog
- Celebrity Paycut - Encouraging celebrities all over the world to save us from global warming by taking a paycut.
- Bailout Vote Fails | D.C. Thornton
- Destroying the economy to win votes; Nancy Pelosi’s speech and Barack Obama’s rhetoric « Northern Thoughts And Reflections
- What The Heck? The Bailout Failed? « Blog Entry « Dr. Melissa Clouthier
- Right Wing News
- Conservative Musings
- The Bailout Dies in the House « Black Coffee & Bourbon
- Congressman Ander Crenshaw Votes for the Bailout « Black Coffee & Bourbon
- Bad Example
- AFNonline » 2008 » October » 01
- Don Surber » Blog Archive » Robin hoodwinked
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Categories: Subprime crisis
Power Line
» More From the East Anglia Archives

American Thinker
» Sarah Palin and the low ebb of the cultural left
Doug Ross @ Journal
» ACORN pwnage part II: Breitbart's BigGovt Lowers the Boom
Big Government
» BREAKING: San Diego ACORN Document Dump Scandal
Villainous Company
» Amateur Hour in the Oval Office Continues....
Nice Deb
» O
Green Room
» Times Slimes Obamic Climes








I agree! ROLFLMAO! This is one pessimistic dude!
Your sitting somewhere in the middle of the work day on a computer, probably with a cable modem attempting to get others to wring their hands about some so-called personal experience you “CLAIM” to have experienced.
Dosen’t really strike me as all that awful from here.
Nice sympathy play though.
however with all that mush, you still ignore how the liberals took us to this point in time.
Not buying it
Thanks though
On September 29th, 2008 at 4:26 pm, mpChops said:
At one point in my life I was homeless for over a year. I clawed my way up without one damned collectivist handout. Now I live a good life due to my own hard work.
I would give it all up and go back on the streets if it meant having to be a slave to the State.
Stick that in your collectivist pipe and suck on it hard.
Perfer et obdura; dolor hic tibi proderit olim!
Amen Film Ladd
i second that amen, Film Ladd…
I can see that nyc123me is very scared, and is drawing on a personal experience as a basis for fear, which I honor as being real. I don’t belittle that. Sharing hope is what helps people.
God bless, nyc123me.
happyscrapper
Just to be clear only the last two sentences were mine
not the homeless rant
Vicki Soup she is blessed.
I assume she is an American
That is the blessing the rest of the world claws its way to get here for.
For themselves and their children
That is a blessing!
I am a conservative Republican, but I also have a brain. Today I am extremely angry at the Republican conservatives who voted no on this bill. I will put my future in the hands of the Fed Chief before or I will put it in the hands of some politicians who apparently don’t have a clue. I put Michelle in that same bin on this issue. Apparently Michelle doesn’t have a clue either. This is a sad day for America. I would now say that Obama will win by a landslide. The Republican party has lost his brain.
Republicans had nothing to do with this vote.
Democrats have a majority in the House
and could not get their own members to support it.
All democrats had to do was vote yes.
Even they turned it down.
Sen. John Kyl, what a sellout tool. “The key thing is not to affix blame.”
When JUSTICE says, “let us not affix blame” then there is no justice!
AZ GOP’ers, yall need to get rid of this guy as soon as you can, he is a Corporate Socialist.
THERE IS BLAME: the blame is the Dems with GOP acquiescence.
JOHN KYL, go on vacation you corporate socialist.
On September 29th, 2008 at 5:15 pm, DanME said:
You’re not a conservative. You’re a pragmatic collectivist. You think it’s okay to have some socialism – just a little bit more slavery – to bail you out on your 401k, or to win the next election, or whatever.
Today was a great day for freedom.
We just have to hold the course and protect ourselves from the vampire next time. Because it will be back. The collectivist b*tch is in full-blown heat.
DanME, this is not a Republican or Democrat problem. It’s an American problem. Blaming others is why nothing can get done in Washington anymore.
Nancy Pelosi, as House Speaker, has not learned that. Harry Reid, as Senate Majority Leader, has not learned that.
They are the party in power and they actually do hold the power, but seem unable to get over their victimhood to get anything done.
It is why their approval rating has been in freefall for the past two years.
When they stop blaming and start acting like grownups, they will be better leaders. Nobody wants to follow the crybaby with a load in their pants.
Ha! Yes, I got that! Actually, I am feeling a bit guity for ridiculing nyc. He may be coming from a totally different place than the rest of us, and if he is legitimate, we should have compassion.
The bailout scares me more than no bailout. It would only put off the day of reckoning and make it worse. It will not even begin to solve the foreclosure problem or oversupply in the market, which will have to work itself out over a period of years. What we will have to do some day is simply cut government spending and balance the budget. Even if it means raising taxes to pay for the party, but no new programs or money down the drain, like this bailout. We have been living in a financial la-la land where everbody gets everything and nobody is left out. The party is over and it is time to face reality.
There will be a good deal of suffering but in the end it will be unavoidable. I work in the construction industry and know the hit we will be taking: it is going to be ugly. However, we survived Jimmy Carter and we will survive this crisis. (BTW, I lived in a third world country for 4 years. I know what suffering is and am convinced that is where we are heading unless we face this thing down, not avoid it). One silver lining will be watching all the youthful Obama supporters finding out how bountiful the Bush years were and what real economic pain looks like.
Just out of curiosity, does anybody remember the so called “friction free economy” and end of recessions that was being trumpeted by the internet new economy gurus back in the 90’s. People would roll their eyes at me when I used to try to explain that the information age only meant people would make bad decisons and overreact more quickly than before, instead of making calm rational decisons that would prevent economic meltdowns. Where are all those new economy gurus now?
Was this a “rope a dope”? The big $$$ bill was allowed to be written up by a bunch of Democrats. Bush’s effort to reach across I guess. At least everyone now knows this Freddie and Fannie biz is a bunch of crap. (a good thing) Also, Russia and other anti-American markets are tanking and they may not weather stuff the way USA can. We may be weakened, but what if our enemy’s are put out of business but good? Oil is down to $95 and that is going to hurt Iran. All bad stuff has a bright side. By the way, anytime someone tells you that you have to act immediately or else, Go for the “or else”. Buying a pig-in-the-poke is an old saying. Lots of people don’t know what that is. This bill was a pig-in-a-poke.
nyc is a guy?
I thought he was a she.
Jeez I should have added grow a pair.
You are right though about not ridiculing someone else. I agree with that, but cannot stomach in this great country someone bellyaching.
When I know the greatness of this county first hand. This country gives each and everyone of us Opportunity.
I grew up dirt poor. I do not blame America, I blame my father and grandfather for not working harder.
I know the only way to get ahead is to ahve a plan. Never blame someone else for my own shortocmings. And never expect it to be easy.
Never think you are entitled to the sweat of another mans brow.
Thank GOD everyday for your being here in America.
If you are not here in America pray for the guidance to allow you to emigrate “Legally” to America.
I could go on but I know you get it
DanMe, you missed the 90 Democrats that voted NO on this? So, go ahead and get angry at the Repub party, as has been mentioned, San Fran Gran Nan did not need a single repub vote. she could have passed this, but for one sad thing, she couldn’t get the rest of her dem congress critters to vote Yea on this..maybe you don’t have the brain you thought you did…
You mean where 18 year olds were being recruited out of high school into $80k/year tech jobs, becoming MOP’s in two years when the companies went public, and then were broke again in 5 years? I do. You are so right about bad decisions and the perils of overreacting.
Where the hell do you get off? Who the hell do you think you’re talking to? You paint those you don’t even know with a broad brush.
I’ve lived through hard times. I know what it’s like to grow up with 2 parents, and one of those parents being out of work and the entire family living on one salary- under 30k. Spare me.
I know what it’s like to be a struggling grad student with no health care and working a dead-end job that paid my basics and not much else. I had so thin a budget that it squeeked. My roommates made fun of me for eating Ramen every night while they lived beyond their means and ate out all the time.
I know that my pathetic excuse for a Roth IRA will be hit. It wasn’t that much to begin with because it’s been unwisely managed. I’m now considering all measure to protect my personal/family investments.
What is your solution? Hmmmm? What do you advise the average employee who doesn’t have a 401K and rather has to find other resources to save their pennies and plan for their retirements?
I fully recognize how bad things can get because my 76 year old father grew up during the Great Depression. I’m 33 years old and have an insight about that period in time that many of my peers will never have and can barely comprehend if they did. I’ve always lived within my means and had a budget (something that is beyond comprehension to the idiots who contributed to this financial crisis). I’ve worked hard all my life and I’m telling you right now that these politicians have no right to screw ME over because they fouled up this economy and decided to ignore it.
Reexamine the situation. Please. Your assumptions make a fool out of you and everybody else.
John Kyl says he wants to “teach us”… we need to “teach” him: we will not be bullied or frightened into accepting socialism!!!!
http://kyl.senate.gov/
Just to be clear on the bailout.
I am not 100% opposed to government intervention in some way.
I am 100% opposed to ignoring the facts which led up to this mess.
Barney Frank, Maxine Waters, Chris Dodd, Nancy Pelosi Chuck Schumer and “Several” others have to go.
At the heart of this problem is liberalism. Till that is addressed we are simply wallpapering over a hole in the wall with winter storms approaching. How is that for an analogy?
I hate analogies!
Till the people who led us to this point are dealt with, NO DEAL!
Retired and on a fixed income, but my husband just reassured me that we have a very diversified portfolio and should be fairly safe. We will lose some, but we do have a pantry full of
Ramen Noodles. No worries.
happy Scrapper
My wife and I have several good Bean and corn bread recipes
God Bless you!
WE’LL BE OK TOO!
I agree. But they shouldn’t just be fired. They need to go to prison. Their actions were criminally complicit in this whole thing. They think they are so powerful that they will get away with it. Oh, how the mighty will fall!
Beans and corn bread…Yum! God bless you too!
I grew up eating pinto beans and cornbread. I consider it a delicacy.
Buy some seeds for a few pennies, plant them, grow some veggies, mix ‘em with Ramen noodles and, voila! That is not a bad meal, actually.
Now that I’m putting it all out there, it is my belief that, if there was no welfare, poverty in America would virtualy cease to exist. If we knew that our neighbor’s next meal or well-being depended upon our kindness toward them, they would be given what they needed. Even if I were broke, perhaps especially if I were broke, I would do everything within my power to take care of them with the blessings God has given me, and I believe you would, too.
Sharing out of our own need is what makes this country great.
So, a corporation with a Billion Dollar market cap. is only down $50 Million.
A Million here…A Million there…Pretty soon, we’ll be talkin’ ’bout real money.
right?
[rolls eyes]
FYI yes I am male. I am not young, but I am not retirement age just yet either. I lived most of my life overseas. I moved to USA in 2001. I am an adult student trying to make something of myself through hard work and almost no income. If you don’t believe me, I don’t care.
Hi again! I’m back! (well sort of…)
My dad sent me this link to my mailbox and I just wanted to share it with you. Read it and pls tell me what you guys think about it.
I believe you, nyc123me, and I care.
On September 29th, 2008 at 5:47 pm, franksalterego said:
Let it drop 10%! 20%! 50%!
I do not exist for the State! I will not be a slave to big socialist corporations for so-called economic security!
It is NOT THE GOVERNMENT’S JOB to PROTECT ANYONE’S 401K!
Freedom is worth 100% of the market’s value!
I wonder if, our little blogger will be so blah-zay, when Corporate America lays off 5% of their workforce to compensate.
Interesting article, edelweiss, if not surprising.
On September 29th, 2008 at 5:51 pm, edelweiss said:
I think most big corporations LOVE socialism and collectivism. They LOVE having the government protect them from competition and small business.
You idiot socialists never seem to get that you’re fighting FOR what the big corporations want! All the while ranting about how “greed” and “big corporations” are evil.
Moronic collectivist pawn!
A posse ad esse non valet consequentia!
Thanks again Vickisoup, it helps.
Yeah, but just maybe it doesn’t require a socialist solution. Or to the extent it does, the corrupt and outrageously incompetent government officials who let this happen (Frank, Dodd et al) should be charged with every credible criminal offense (influence-peddling, bribe-taking etc.) and forced to resign.
In any other country, such officials would already be in disgrace, in jail (or in places like china) in the ground.
If we allow these perps to “skate” we will deserve every bit of misery they have created.
OK, scarier than the market’s drop today? The picture of Nancy Pelosi on the drudgereport home page.
On September 29th, 2008 at 5:54 pm, nyc123me said:
I believe you. I was in your position. And you can work your way out of it on your own!
Collectivism is NOT the answer.
fulldroolcup, read all of my comments. We are in agreement.
My point was that Dems need to stop blaming and start doing something, but they never seem to learn.
There isn’t a very long growing season here in Minnesnowda, but my husband and I always buy a lot of things when they are on sale and we have a very large, fully stocked pantry. We also believe in eating up our leftovers! I even sometimes re-use aluminum foil, a habit I picked up from my dear old mom.
Re: Drudge photo. Does Nancy Pelosi have lock jaw? Now that would be a good thing!
After reading most of the comments, it is clear that you most of your don’t really have much in the way of education or insight. In other words that you can understand, you are as dumb as a rock. The bill was bad, the government made the crisis, so we are all feeling better that we stopped them from allowing us to get screwed. Or did we.
Marie, it could just be too much botox.
What country did you come from?
This made me piddle.
Faith does not guarantee life or exemption from extreme hardship, nor is the USA exempt from the 7 seals.
Ironic. The Fed is pumping an additional $630 billion into the system anyway. Great. Maybe that will stop things crashing as hard, but I doubt we’ll see any of it back. I think I need to step away from the computer for a while.
FilmLadd, yeah I know – I wouldn’t be here doing it in the first place if I thought there was no point.
For the first time in my adult life I am proud of Congress!
David we have not stopped anything.
They are simply going back for more discussions behind the scenes which you and I will never know about. Probably??
Thus we will be revisiting this issue later this week or next.
Will that legislation be any better than this? Who knows.
Between now and then expect the newsmedia to ratchet up the doom and gloom predictions.
Will they come true? Again who knows.
But if all they have to do to make us do what they want is to ratchet up fear. Then we’re screwed already.
As I stated earlier, I am not 100 % against some type of intervention.
However I do not trust the people who caused this crisis to correct it any better than they wrecked it.
I would happily give all my money and every one of my worldly possessions in exchanged for freedom from the tyranny of a Socialist government. God has Blessed me and I want to make sure my kids can enjoy these same liberties in their lifetimes.
nyc123me – make sure you understand what this bailout would mean (in it’s current form) to the country. You came to America for a reason. Think about that before you “vote” to throw it all away.
I just saw this quote on a DRUDGE link.
“We are now in the golden age of thieves. And where I come from we put thieves in jail, we don’t bail them out.” — Rep. Pete Visclosky, Democrat.
While I do not know who he means, I agree with the sentiment.
I simply think the first in line should be Franklin Raines, Jamie Gorelick, Barney Frank, Chris Dodd, Chuck Schumer, Maxine Waters, among others.
We can add to this list, but I doubt anyone would remove any of these names.
Likewise. But if it’s going to happen, I’d like to see it involve reversing the stupid decisions which led us to this point. For instance, CRA should be scrapped. No bank should ever be pressured to lend money to bad credit risks. And Fannie and Freddie should be scrapped or made completely private.
I could, reluctantly, go along with some sort of bail-out. But they MUST correct the underlying problems. Otherwise we’ll just go through this all over again in another dozen years.
I make a mean mayonaise sandwich! When time are tough, I can cut back to air sandwiches too.
Here is my one piece of relatively serious financial advice. (note that it is free)
Now might not be the time to invest in the ‘dietary aids’ or the ‘male performance enhancing’ markets!
I know that a lot of you are cheering that the bail out did not pass, but let me point out one thing.
A 800 point drop in the stock market is never a good thing. Ever.
Per my post on the other thread.
Times are tough all over
Yes, most of the most of us don’t. Mostly
Hear, Hear! FilmLadd #408
Again, it isn’t even on the top 10 list if you use a percentage basis.
Mike Rogers from Michigan voted no, and was on the radio later. I was really optimistic after hearing him. He outlined a 3 point plan that wouldn’t cost the taxpayers a dime.
Of course, I’ll bet the Democrats would never sign on to a plan like that.
On September 29th, 2008 at 7:03 pm, hayroller15 said:
Thank you.
On September 29th, 2008 at 6:53 pm, AnotherBrian said:
If it means my freedom and the freedom of my children, it’s a great thing. A glorious thing. A thing to be celebrated.
Are you saying your freedom is worth 777 points?
franksalterego said:
It’s dropped less than 5 percent.
I wonder if, our little blogger will be so blah-zay, when Corporate America lays off 5% of their workforce to compensate.
As long as it’s the 5% tht makes up the illegal population…
Earlier I was convinced someone had posted a link to the wrong bill… but apparently I simply didn’t understand how THIS could be the bill title!
What is up with THAT?
nice quote old college guy #428. Visclosky is a Hoosier Rep that voted “nay” on this piece of art…
I guess we can thank Pelosi. If she hadn’t opened her tight lips, this might have passed.
Interesting that the Dow lost 777 points. Bible prophecy is big on 7’s.
Paul Ryan said aye. What the—
It’s also helpful if you can tell the difference between rain, and someone peeing on you.
$700 billion bailout proposal, the Dow sinks 777 points, or 7 percent in value….that’s a whole lotta 7’s.
Not sure if it means anything but just sayin’….
Maybe it is time for survival of the fittest? Let the welfare losers die, the illegals go home.
Would I give a large portion of my wealth to get rid of the Mexicans and the Black gang members???
YES! I would live in a safe country, rather than in the hip hop taco shop that Southern California has become.
Rob, ouch. Your comment hurts even the reader.
Yuppers, this was a “rope a dope” tactic
as I listen to Rove on Fox News.
Palosi didn’t want this to pass. She wanted it to fail to blame Repubs.
Yep, and Odumbo’s poll numbers are increasing. It’s working for them. Wonderful. Now we’re going to have socialized (nationalized) banking system, along with healthcare. Oh boy, I can’t wait.
NOT.
Senator Shelby
Shelby of Alabama had a letter signed by 200 economists from Universities and Think Tanks from around the country. In the meeting with Bush Thursday, the president said “I don’t care what college professors think.” Shelby walked out of the meeting right then. Bush was pushing this through because he was worried about his legacy. My Rep. Dr. Tom Price (R) voted No and I am proud of him. This was not a time to socialize Wall Street. I’m calling my broker tomorrow and going to look for some deals to buy on the DOW and NASDAQ. All weekend long Pelosi, Reid, Schumer, Dodd and Frank were blaming all this on the GOP yet their fingerprints are all over this mess. The GOP has 35 days to make sure the undecideds get the message. I bet they do! This election will go down in history as the wildest. Let’s hope there is a landslide on November 4th, or lawyers will be descending on Secretary of States like no other time before. Time to Rock the Vote and help McCain/Palin return some civility to DC.
Davidcaskey, your are right mosetly. My education are not mosetly good.
Here in what has become Mexian, Black land.. it hurts every damn day.
I go for a walk in my neighborhood with my wife, and I get HARD looks from the blacks and Mexicans sitting in groups on the curb or in the driveways in an area that ten years ago was safe and nice.
I went to the 7/11 yesterday to get gas, and a loud, rap-playing, car full of young gang member blacks sat at blared their noise and acted tough.
Even the signs are becoming Mexican.
It HURTS you to read it? How about living it?
Mexico, coming to a neighborhood near you….
On September 29th, 2008 at 7:40 pm, vickisoup said:
I’m not a believer but that struck me as odd too.
Also found it odd that Shep Smith rounded up to 778 for his report. Weird.
Alea iacta est!
On September 29th, 2008 at 7:15 pm, FilmLadd said:
Well, let’s put it this way: Your freedom isn’t worth a whole lot when the companies that employ you are going out of business.
People have to face facts. If you want to earn money, you give up a certain amount of your freedom.
The economy in a melt down is not conducive to freedom.
On September 29th, 2008 at 8:25 pm, Rob said:
I grew up in New Orleans. CA has lots of pretty bad spots, but nothing on the Fischer Housing Projects pre-Katrina (haven’t been to N.O. since then so I can’t say what it’s doing these days).
Any caucasian stupid enough to walk through it back then would likely meet death in a few seconds.
Pehaps we DON’T want to earn more money if it means we can’t live in a safe and sane place live.
We love the internet, but is all the sex, porn crap worth it?
If we all have to live in tents cooking over firewood, but don’t have to deal with the losers that get welfare, steal, tag, deal drugs, kill our children, get free lunches..etc.,
Perhaps, we would be a hell of a lot safer and happier.
Perhaps THAT is real freedom.
My wife is NOT allowed out after dark by herself here in Southern California…. it is like Nightmare On Hellstreet, and realize, this was an area that used to be a Leave it to Beaver “hood” not long ago..
On September 29th, 2008 at 8:31 pm, AnotherBrian said:
What? What? You’ve missed out on a lot of discussions on this subject in previous posts.
Let’s establish a few things.
When you earn money you are engaging in freedom. Money is the transmission of value between two people. If you work for me, you are willingly giving over your time for money, and vice-versa.
You do not “surrender” your freedom. You are engaging in a contract to perform work. This contract is engaged in of your own free will.
If the company I work for goes out of business, I am free to work elsewhere! I am free to start my own business! I am free to go eat grass in the park!
But what no human being should ever be able to do is use the STATE to CONFISCATE money from other people to protect an INVESTMENT.
THAT IS EVIL.
Let’s get another thing straight.
No one forced anyone to sell their stocks today! No one forced anyone to buy stocks today!
People could have refused to sell their stocks at the prices offered. They had their reasons to sell. LET THEM.
The government is not GOD. It can not wade in and determine who should win and who should lose. It does not have the OMNISCIENCE to determine what prices should be in the stock market.
I say it again: my freedom is NOT WORTH 100% of the Dow Jones Industrial Average!
Caeci caecos ducentes!
On September 29th, 2008 at 8:40 pm, Rob said:
It’s a stupid question probably, but why not move?
sigh… yeah…
They tagged on the fence next door two days ago…
Sure, this is the time to sell.. ha…
I think the 1950’s was the time to live…
On September 29th, 2008 at 8:45 pm, Rob said:
Don’t give up! There are always options if you work at it. I just sold my house two weeks ago and made a pretty good profit.
It wasn’t easy though.
Had to do dry wall work, painting, cleaning. Moved out all of my stuff into a storage unit. Took six months of working at it. Lot of sore muscles.
Hear, Hear! again FilmLadd #458
Tell ‘em how it is.
Stock market declines are very healthy when the wealth that is “destroyed” during the fall never really existed in the first place. Who here understands what gives the stock market value? The dollar? Who here recognizes a buying opportunity when they see one?
Who here understands that when a society consumes more than it produces it is living on borrowed time?
At least today’s turn-of-events make the Presidential election meaningful, again… sort of.