Liveblogging the last presidential debate of 2008
It begins at 9pm Eastern.
Liberal Beltway fixture Bob Schieffer moderates. I noted in 2004 that he asked a question about immigration during one of the 2004 debates. Wouldn’t it be novel if the subject finally came up tonight? Not that the La Raza twins would differ much. I’m not the only one who wants to hear some border talk. The Plumber Joe Wurzelbach mentioned it, too.
Got your ACORN martinis, ready?
Drinking game buzz words:
GREED.
GREEDY.
RESCUE.
EARMARKS.
TAX CREDITS.
WALL STREET.
MAIN STREET.
HEALTH CARE.
JUDGEMENT.
BUSH. BUSH. BUSH.
BIPARTISAN.
CLIMATE CHANGE.
Commenter Jencab: “You forgot…”
UUUHHHH
MY FRIENDS
ACROSS THE AISLE
WHEELS OF THE STRAIGHT TALK EXPRESS
I AGREE
MIDDLE CLASS
9:02pm Eastern. Schieffer starts right off the bad with the Dow plunge today. Why is your plan better than his?
McCain: Americans are hurting and they’re angry. Their innocent victims of GREED and WALL STREET.
Drink, drink, drink up.
McCain: They are hurting and they’re angry.
Ok, we get it.
Now, he’s promoting home ownership and preservation at any cost. Pitches his rotten individual mortgage rescue plan. “Put home owners first.”
McCain criticizes Paulson for “not making it their first priority.”
Only superficial mention of Fannie/Freddie.
I repeat what I said earlier today: Hey, chumps: Why are you still paying your mortgages?
Obama: RESCUE package for the MIDDLE CLASS.
My glass is half-empty already.
Obama: TAX CREDIT.
Gulp again.
Obama: Sen. McCain, I AGREE with helping homeowners.
Glass is empty.
McCain brings up The Plumber: Joe, I wanna tell ya. I want to keep your taxes low, affordable health care, I will not stand for tax increases on small business income. What you want to do to Joe the plumber is…have them not live the American Dream.
Obama brings up his 95 percent tax cut fantasy.
McCain blasts Obama for his “spread the wealth around” ideology. I want Joe the Plumber to spread the wealth around. Why would you want to increase anyone’s taxes right now? I’m not going to do that in my administration.
Obama invokes his friend, billionaire Warren Buffett in response.
Not such a bright move there, Barry.
We’re talking about a plumber and Obama leans on one of the richest men in the world as a crutch?
McCain: We need to cut people’s taxes, create jobs, not “spread the wealth around.”
Good. He drove that nail.
9:14pm Eastern. Schieffer asks what specific programs the candidates would cut.
Obama has been blabbing for two minutes without naming anything specific. Blahblahblahblah. He’s talking about making “investments” to prevent diseases.
He STILL hasn’t mentioned a single program.
9:16pm Eastern. McCain should have nailed Obama immediately for failing to name a single program he would cut, but he wants to return to the home ownership/prevention crap. Increasing home values. Blahblahblah. McCain segues into energy independence.
Finally, an answer.
McCain: What would I cut? Across-the-board spending freeze. Some people say it’s a hatchet. I’ll do the hatchet and then the scalpel. Would cut marketing assistance, ethanol subsidies, I know how to save billions.
Grab your drinks: McCain mentions EARMARKS.
9:21pm Eastern. McCain repeats his line that Americans are angry. Pledges to balance the budget in four years. You have to tell me one time when you’ve stood up to the leaders of your party.
Obama: Cites tort reform, charter schools. He slips in a reference to Fox News agreeing with him.
Obama moves to his BUSH-McCain talking points.
McCain: Elaborates on his opposition to Bush administration. I’ve got the scars to prove it. Cites CLIMATE CHANGE. Your record of independence isn’t very convincing.
Schieffer moves to the tone of the campaign. Obama says “erratic,” “losing his bearings, etc.” McCain says “lie,” “palling around with terrorists,” etc. “Are you each willing to say to each other’s face what you’ve said in ads.”
McCain goes first. “It’s gotten tough and I regret some of it.” Blames Obama for not accepting Town Hall proposals. McCain calls out John Lewis for comparing him to George Wallace and calls out Obama for not repudiating him. Very unfair and totally inappropriate. We will run a truthful campaign. A tough campaign. Obama has spent more on negative ads than any campaign in history. He said he would take public financing if I did. He didn’t keep his word. You didn’t tell the American people the truth.
Obama: We expect presidential campaigns to be tough. Whines that McCain’s ads were 100 percent negative and says people don’t want to hear about their hurt feelings. Plays the distraction card.
Obama will not repudiate John Lewis’s remarks, then says “politics as usual” is no longer acceptable.
McCain attacks Obama’s health care and immigration ads. Invokes Joe the Plumber again.
Obama smirks.
McCain: I did not hear repudiation of Congressman Lewis’s remarks.
Obama whines about the purported catcalls at the Palin rallies and rationalizes Lewis’s remarks. Whines about the “palling around with terrorists” jibe. It’s an opening to talk about Ayers…but McCain’s not biting for whatever reason.
9:33pm Eastern. McCain defends the people who attend his rallies.
KNOCK ME OVER WITH A FEATHER. He’s defending the base. “I’m not going to stand for that!”
You just scored some points, McCain.
FINALLY!
McCain: I’ve seen t-shirts that are unacceptable. Things yelled at your rallies.
FINALLY! Rejecting the “mob narrative.”
9:35pm Eastern. McCain ate his Wheaties. He mentions old, washed-up terrorist Ayers and Acorn – destroying the fabric of our nation.
Obama gives his talking points about Ayers (I was eight years old) and ACORN (I represented them in a lawsuit with the Justice Department).
McCain better set the record straight.
9:38pm Eastern. McCain says he launched his political campaign in Ayers’ living room. Mentions Ayers’ 2001 regret that he hadn’t bombed more.
Well, was that enough, folks? What do you think?
I think it’s the best we can expect McCain to have done.
The McCain campaign e-mails the talking points McCain failed to recite…
ACORN’s Political Action Committee Endorsed Barack Obama For President. “[A]CORN’s political action committee endorsed Barack Obama for President. … The endorsement reflects a belief that Obama – who worked as a community organizer on the South Side of Chicago – understands that change must come from the ground-up, as part of a working coalition, rather than from position papers.” (Katrina Vanden Heuvel, Op-Ed, “ACORN: Obama Gets It,” The Nation, 2/23/08)
Barack Obama’s Campaign “Paid More Than $800,000″ To ACORN For Get-Out-The Vote Efforts; The Campaign Originally “Misrepresented” The Group’s Work To The FEC. “U.S. Sen. Barack Obama’s presidential campaign paid more than $800,000 to an offshoot of the liberal Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now for services the Democrat’s campaign says it mistakenly misrepresented in federal reports. An Obama spokesman said Federal Election Commission reports would be amended to show Citizens Services Inc. — a subsidiary of ACORN — worked in ‘get-out-the-vote’ projects, instead of activities such as polling, advance work and staging major events as stated in FEC finance reports filed during the primary.” (David M. Brown, “Obama To Amend Report On $800,000 In Spending,” Pittsburgh Tribune Review, 8/22/08)
Barack Obama Directed Project Vote And Later Taught Classes For “Future Leaders Identified By ACORN And The Centers For New Horizons.” “In 1992 Obama took time off to direct Project Vote, the most successful grass-roots voter-registration campaign in recent city history. Credited with helping elect Carol Moseley-Braun to the U.S. Senate, the registration drive, aimed primarily at African-Americans, added an estimated 125,000 voters to the voter rolls–even more than were registered during Harold Washington’s mayoral campaigns. ‘It’s a power thing,’ said the brochures and radio commercials. … Obama continues his organizing work largely through classes for future leaders identified by ACORN and the Centers for New Horizons on the south side.” (Hank De Zutter, Op-Ed, “What Makes Obama Run?” Chicago Reader, 12/8/95)
· In 1992, Barack Obama Was Hired By ACORN To Run A Voter Registration Effort. “Indeed, Mr. Obama has extensive connections with the granddaddy of activist groups, Acorn (Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now), which has gotten millions in government grants for its low-income housing programs. In 1992, Acorn hired Mr. Obama to run a voter registration effort. He later became a trainer for the group, as well as its lawyer in election law cases. Acorn’s political arm has endorsed Mr. Obama while its ‘voter education’ arm has pledged to spend $35 million to register people this fall — despite a history of vote fraud scandals that have led to guilty pleas by many Acorn employees.” (John Fund, “Obama’s Liberal Shock Troops,” The Wall Street Journal, 7/12/08)
Barack Obama Was Part Of Team Of Lawyers Who Represented ACORN In A Suit Against The State Of Illinois. “Obama was part of a team of attorneys who represented the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now (ACORN) in a lawsuit against the state of Illinois in 1995 for failing to implement a federal law designed to make it easier for the poor and others to register as voters.” (Mike Robinson, “Obama Got Start In Civil Rights Practice,” The Associated Press, 2/20/07)
ACORN Received Grants From The Woods Fund When Barack Obama Served on The Board Of Directors
· The Chicago ACORN Received Grants Of $45,000 (2000), $30,000 (2001), $45,000 (2001), $30,000 (2002), And $40,000 (2002) From The Woods Fund. (Donors Forum Website, ifs.donorsforum.org, Accessed 6/10/08)
· NOTE: From 1993 To 2002, Barack Obama Served On The Board Of Directors For The Woods Fund. (Tim Novak and Fran Spielman, “Obama Helped Ex-Boss Get $1 Mil. From Charity,” Chicago Sun-Times, 11/29/07)
9:41pm Eastern. Schieffer asks each candidate why their vp candidate would be a better prez than the other’s vp candidate.
Obama gives obligatory Joe is Great spiel with requisite Violence Against Women Act reference and is now talking about “INVESTING” again. Make it a drinking word.
McCain: Sarah Palin is a reformer. She understands families with special needs. She’s ignited our party and people who have never been involved in the political process.
Reader Dustin writes that McCain should have said “Not only do I think Palin would be better than Biden, I believe she’d be better and more experienced than Barack Obama.”
Schieffer asks Obama if Palin is qualified. “That will be up to the American people to decide,” then throws in a jab at McCain on special needs. Says it will take more spending.
McCain: Biden’s qualified in many respects, but has been wrong on foreign policy that’s supposed to be his strength. Cockamamie idea of dividing Iraq in three parts. Wrong about the first Gulf War. National security.
Then McCain jabs Obama back over relying on new spending as solution to everything.
9:47pm Eastern. CLIMATE CHANGE!
Obama is especially smirky tonight, isn’t he?
9:52pm Eastern. McCain dings Obama for opposing Colombia free trade agreement. “Obama, who’s never traveled south of our border…”
McCain slips in Obama’s tea-with-dictators stance. Obama smirks and snorts.
9:59pm Eastern. Health care. McCain is really using Joe the Plumber to great effect. Invokes him again and asks what fine Obama would impose on him if he doesn’t meet Obama’s mandates.
McCain uses a bogus Michael Moore statistic: See the 47 million uninsured lie.
10:04pm Eastern. McCain challenges Obama’s big government policies and mistakenly calls Obama “Sen. Government.”
Yeah, that works.
10:08pm Eastern. Schieffer throws in a SCOTUS question. McCain and Obama agree they wouldn’t apply a litmus test. Obama invokes Roe v. Wade.
McCain better bring up Obama’s lies about his born-alive survivors bill vote.
10:11pm Eastern. YES! He’s finally making up for all those missed opportunities. McCain nails Obama for his extreme, pro-abortion votes. “That’s his record. He voted in direct contradiction to the feelings of mainstream America.”
Obama spins. Filibusters.
McCain rejoinder to Obama — nails him on disingenuous “health of the mother” language/loopholes. Mentions that he and Cindy are adoptive parents, but that doesn’t mean we won’t continue to stand for the rights of the unborn.
Very eloquent. Good job, McCain. (See, who says I can’t say nice things about Mac?)
10:16pm Eastern. Last question is on education.
I’m tuning out Obama. He just said “INVEST” for the 998th time tonight. Blahblah.
McCain calls education the civil rights issue of the 21st century. Talks about choice, parental empowerment. Give parents the same choice that the Obamas have and Cindy and I have to send their kids to good schools. Throwing money is not the answer to the problem. You will find that some of the worst public school districts get the most money.
BINGO.
10:21pm Eastern. Schieffer asks if there should be increased federal role in education. Obama says yes despite the failure of No Child Left Behind. Pay teachers more, fund early childhood education. I AGREE with McCain on charter schools, says Obama. Opposes vouchers.
McCain dings Obama again for exercising his own school choice, but not allowing other parents to do the same.
Obama called on people to put down their video games, but as a McCain staffer e-mails: “But he advertises on them? Disingenuousness.”
Obama tries to rationalize his opposition to vouchers.
McCain sums it up for him: “So because there aren’t enough vouchers we shouldn’t have any even if they work. Got it.”
Obama claims that DC superintendent only supports charter schools, not vouchers. McCain corrects him. Obama sticks to his claim.
Obama is wrong. McCain is right. More here.
Obama: Out-of-touch with minority families demanding choice in D.C.
Debate wrap-up here.
***
11:09pm Eastern Hillary is on Fox News (!) praising Obama through gritted teeth. She says that Joe the Plumber will be “appreciably more positively impacted” by Obama’s policies vs. McCain’s.
“Appreciably more positively impacted?”
And they call Sarah Palin inarticulate…
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Trackbacks
- The Final Debate (thank God!): Live hate-blogging at 8:45 p.m. | I'm Surrounded By Idiots
- Live-blogging the final Debate? | The Anchoress
- Final Presidential Debate - McCan or McCain’t? « Above My Pay Grade!
- Liveblogging and Live Streaming the Final Presidential Debate : Stop The ACLU
- The Other McCain: The final debate
- The Third And Final Presidential Debate: Open Thread | Right Voices
- do they have to wear opposite color ties and other debate comments from a fourth grader « at home with Guinever
- Flopping Aces » Blog Archive » Reactions To Tonight’s Debate
- Sippin’ the debate « No 634
- Live Blogging Debate #3: Last Chance Johnny | Democrat=Socialist
- The Irascible Chef » Bollo Punch! POW!
- MishMashZone » McCain: I Am Not President Bush
- Presidential Debate Liveblog! v3.0 « WitSnapper | The Blog
- McCain Hits the Nail but Fails to Finish the Job | The Daily Conservative
- The Baltimore Reporter
- Senator Government and Johnny McSoft - Lost Opportunities But Still Standing | The Hill Chronicles
- The College Politico » Blog Archive » McCain in the debate, good or bad? What do you think?
- McCain Did A GREAT Job: I AM NOT GEORGE BUSH IF YOU WANTED TO RUN AGAINST HIM YOU SHOULD HAVE DONE SO 4 YEARS AGO « Dianej’s Weblog
- Missed Opportunities | Nicholas Fitzgerald
- Final Debate Establishes Clear Winner: Joe The Plumber « Grand Rants
- McCain Pummels Smirking Obama « Quipster
- Such is Life
- The Final Debate « Gunservatively!
- Thomas König » Blog Archive » Joe the plumber
- Jesus is Lord, A Worshipping Christian’s Blog » Blog Archive » “Liveblogging the last presidential debate of 2008″ by Michelle Malkin
- Lump on a Blog » Blog Archive » Obama's Trickle Up Poverty
- In the eye of the beholder | Civil Commotion
- Joe Wurzelbacher; The man who ended Barack’s dream « Northern Thoughts And Reflections
- Baseball vs. presidential debate…baseball wins « Right Minded Online
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Categories: Barack Obama, John McCain
Right Pundits
» Joe Lieberman: Fort Hood Shooter Is ‘Home-Grown Terrorist’Legal Insurrection
» Bruni de la Motte for Health Care CzarRiehl World View
» Obama: No Military Death Shall Go UnexploitedLegal Insurrection
» In The End: No Public Option, No Abortions, No Pelosi, No ReidThe Other McCain
» Paralysis by analysisThe Powers That Be
» Obama: ‘Don’t Jump to Conclusions’ About Ft. Hood; Immediately Jumps to ConclusionsLegal Insurrection
» NY Times Names Names
Has McCain promised Joe the Plumber a job at the White House as the Secretary of Water Management????
John is right.. Obama care will be just like the DMV.
yippee … the no employer provided insurance fine … nailed to the wall
RUDE.
S-O-C-I-A-L-I-S-T
Back to Joe the plumber..Go John!
ROFL – Joe the Plumber getting a lot of press!!!!
I…I…I….no fines. Go to his website fast & find it!
NHS in England is a failure. Just read the papers about the horror stories every day!
Joe already talked to you, and didn’t buy it. I don’t think he wants to talk to you anymore.
Which “small” businesses do you exempt?!
The 250kers again?
Also, have to kill the earnings for John Edwards and his buddies, and prevent teh lawyer get rich schemes like Mesothelioma, Cerebal Palsy, and teh like. Lawyers do not need to get rich because they found a lot of unfortunate people and doctors with fat insurance policies
Right on dcbprime! No, wait a minute. I won’t get a job. Instead I’ll whine to politicians and maybe I’ll get a handout.
Joe and Mav must be homies…LOL!
Don’t think joe wants to hear from you BHO…LOL, he is losing big time, i wonder how msnbc is gonna spin this.
Tell us how you define “small business” Obambi!
It depends what is is, doesn’t it?
how large DOPE?
Oh no keeping secrets. I won’t tell.
When did Obama exempt small businesses and what is the definition of a small business. Mac is looking shocked!
McCain has gotten a lot of mileage out of Joe. Go Joe.
Barry’s trying not to look mad.
So arrogant. Deciding who can and can’t afford his precious *fines* for health care crimes. Hey, I like that term: “Health Care Crimes”.
That could be a special department Barry can set up.
It ain’t a fine, it’s just a cute little kitty. Gee, I’ll be happy to pay for a kitty!
BHO just exposed his “nanny state” Socialism when talking about health care. Did anybody catch the near final comment about about heart disease and diabetes? He will mandate you eat/drink what he says you can and you better lose weight or else! The dudes very frightening.
Large business already provide insurance. What the hell is Obama talking about. Call him on it McCain. He is lying.
Obama is changing his proposals on the fly here …
I hope Joe opens a branch down here. I’ll call him.
Now he is lying about no cost to small businesses for health care. BS! How the hell you going to pay for that Barry? Oh that’s right the rest of us have to pay the bill for them.
Is BO making up this health insurance thing as he goes along? All this info is brand new.
The one is in drugs. I love Joe the plumber!!
Oh, so if you make over $250K, you are big enough to be taxed, but not fined, and we will give you a credit too…
And accountant’s dream…
We exterminate.. uh.. uh.. I mean exempt small business….. Yeah right.
Feebz, I think Joe is married – LOL
Yeah, how about that frivolous lawsuit situation? Bring that up!!!!!
Solve the illegal alien problem and a lot of those emergency room uncompensated visits go away!!!
Obama is talking into the camera. What a dolt, right Chris?
When I had a business the health insurance for the employees was 100% deductible, I had to pay taxes on mine.
i’d vote for joe the plummer for POTUS over bo&jo
He’s running through the rolodex in his mind and keeps losing track.
Why is OB getting more time?????
is mccain, going to get a chance to respond?
PMSNBC is already frothing at the mouth.
So, they can’t afford McCain’s plan…but Obama’s “mandates” won’t drive up costs?
Hit him on health care – run the numbers.
McCain needs to say that the Dems suddenly seem to care about taxes.
Socialist BA$T@RD! Show your TRUE colors!
Obama is rambling around……
what the hell is BHO talking about??????
Obama is getting a Helluva lot more talking time than Mac
McCain is smirking now!!
I’ll have what he’s having!!!
Sarah must have whacked him with that bag ‘o’ diapers that she bought today!!
Whatever it takes…..
Why does BO get uninterrupted, but JM gets broken in to all the time?
The average policy does NOT cost $12k. That is a lie. I work in the biz.
Pinocchio. Pants, on fire, hanging from a telephone wire.
More emphasis on Glowbama’s anti-Americanism crap is needed NOW!
I am 62 and my insurance costs me less than 5K/year … so where the hell is BO getting his 12k number …
the tax on 12 thou is, like, 5 grand
Execution is everything, Sen. Obama. You have two countries showing just how difficult it is to execute national health care. Learn from that.
Yeah, especially here in CA…we’ve shut down so many I can’t how many now!
AlGore and Mike Dukakis are thrilled with this stump speech wonk talk on healthcare
Barry doesn’t like Mav talking to Joe the Plumber…WAAAAAAA!
Can you imagine what an Obama, Pelosi, Reed lead government will bring to our country. Yep, be really scared.
Joe is really popular tonight.
I’m a healthy 47 yo woman who smokes and drinks, I can find health insurance for less that 1K per month.
McCain got Joe’s last name right at least.
HOLY CRAP..GO JOHN!!!
Seriously, RUN THE NUMBERS!
To Obama a small business is one which has income of $250K annually. Many businesses with $1 million annual income are by SBA definition are small businesses subject to Obamas increased taxation.
Big government at its WORST. But I know what you mean Mac
A BIG SLAP!!!! YEEEOOOOOOCCHHHH. I Felt that one all the way down here in Florida.
Who says the government will pay all your health care? Where did that come from? $12,000, really???
Who says the government will pay all your health care? Where did that come from? $12,000, really???
“Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy.” – Winston Churchill
The MSM will have to give the Obama-Joe interaction some attention now.
The fine is 0 for small business??
I guaran-damn-tee you that the business Joe wants to buy makes more than 250K a year! Come on – at 40K/sal and then all the extra FICA and ESC and benefits and equipment and business insurance – Joe’s business could only have like 5 employees!! Give me a break!
Ask the questions – does Obama mean business that GROSS 250K? or Profit??
AAAAAAACK!
Let Obama talk, hes REALLY boring.
Cosmetic surgery? Transplants?
You listening Biden? He’s talking to you!!!
Thank you, John McCain.
Odumbo is flustered.
I still don’t understand McCains plan. Thank God I don’t need it.
Oh boy, Mac’s got the Obama smile down. Wow, keep talking about Joe! Joe is going to be the republican’s hero! Wonder if he will get an invite to McCain’s swearing in?
Cross state competition will save money on health insurance.
:places Rogue’s hand in warm water:
BWAHHHAHAHAHAHHAHHAHA
“more americans will receive more money under my plan”… good lord, Johnny. you’re ALMOST good. Loose the socialist schtick, and I go along with ya…
Senator Goverment hahaha
Sen. Government!!!
Senator Government!
SENATOR GOVERNMENT!!!
Senator Government!!!!
HAHAHA
Senator Government.. I like that..
I wish McCain had done this months ago. Maybe a bit late to wake up but hopefully not.
Socialism works for people who don’t.
Capitalism works for people who do!
Senator “Government”????
ROFLOL!!!!
Senator Government. Now that’s funny.
Obama sure has some bright choppers!
“Senator Government”…now THAT’s the best Freudian slip of the night!
HA!
Go Johnny Go!
HOT DANG! GO JOHN GO!!!! Lovin’ it!
“Senator Government”
PERFECT!!
SENATOR GOVERNMENT!!! Excellent!
I am over 50, smoke, don’t drink, and my insurance is $330 per month.
You’re not a democrat, you’re a Marxist.
Mav’s called out the Donkeycrat Congress…YEA BUDDY!!!
same sentiment crashemt
Maybe Obama is on to something….all the dead people’s votes can’t be wrong.
The US Chamber of Commerce may be pulling their support really soon.