Robert Reich, quote doctor
You’ll be interested to know that Professor Bob has shut down his comment section on his “Open Letter” blog post to me and other critics of his color-coded stimulus earmarks.
Perhaps in response to his bogus, Media Matters-echoing accusations that we were twisting his words, someone posted a link to this 1997 Slate piece exposing Reich’s own serial penchant for quote-doctoring. (hat tip – Ed Driscoll) An excerpt:
Again and again, Reich offers zippy dramatic dialogues culminating in pithy and revealing quotes. For instance, he has Robert Michel, R-Ill., who was House minority leader at the time, telling him this about Newt Gingrich and friends: “They talk as if they’re interested in ideas, in what’s good for America. But don’t be fooled. They’re out to destroy. They’ll try to destroy anything that gets in their way, using whatever tactics are available.” Reich may believe Michel said this, but Michel says he knows otherwise. “That’s not my quote, no,” he says. Michel says he probably complained about the decline of comity and bipartisanship. But “I would never say that–that they’re out to destroy. I’d never say anything like it.”
Reich says that on March 18, 1993, Democratic Rep. Martin Olav Sabo of Minnesota, House Budget Committee chairman, told him this about congressional Democrats: “We’re owned by them. Business. That’s where the campaign money comes from now.” But Sabo says that he could not have spoken with Reich on March 18 (they did talk on March 2) and that, in any case, he neither said nor believes that Democrats are owned by business. Reich “certainly does not capture the substance of any conversation I ever had with him,” Sabo wrote to the Minneapolis Star Tribune. Reich also reports a conversation in which he tells Rep. David Obey, D-Wis., his theory about blue-collar hostility toward Clinton. The vignette ends with Obey saying: “You’re either a genius or you’re nuts. If I were you, I wouldn’t share that theory with anyone else.” Obey says, through an aide, that he’s sure he never said that, since he was talking up a similar theory himself–though he says the rest of the conversation seems accurate. Former head of the AFL-CIO Lane Kirkland, whom Reich portrays unsympathetically in several private dialogues, protested in a recent letter to Reich: “I did not, in fact, utter the words that you attribute to me in various places, in direct quotation marks, as though you were repeating my words verbatim.”
Asked about these denials, Reich said, “Our recollections differ.” And it’s certainly true that, in Washington, quote-denying is endemic. But some of Reich’s dialogues are checkable, and turn out, when checked, to be inaccurate in ways that serve Reich’s rhetorical ends.
Like I said yesterday: Pot. Kettle.
***
Related: Noel Sheppard sees an Obama-Limbaugh-Malkin-Reich-Media Matters Connection.
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
 |
Inevitable: Obama Surpasses Bush in Debt Increase
March 20, 2012 01:12 PM by Doug Powers
95 Comments
Joe Biden: Economic Theories of GOP Candidates Will Lead America to Bankruptcy
March 16, 2012 04:04 PM by Doug Powers
85 Comments
White House Proposal to Stimulate Volt Sales: Jack up the Taxpayer Subsidy to $10,000 Per Car
March 8, 2012 02:04 PM by Doug Powers
104 Comments
Stimulus-Backed ‘Green’ Bankruptcy of the Week: Ener1
January 26, 2012 03:06 PM by Doug Powers
67 Comments
Obama’s Green Robber Barons
January 25, 2012 09:13 AM by Michelle Malkin
89 CommentsWhite House Calls Solyndra Subpoena ‘Unreasonable Burden on the President’s Ability to Meet His Constitutional Duties’
November 5, 2011 10:22 AM by Doug Powers
84 Comments
California High Speed Rail Project Triples in Projected Cost, Won’t Be Ready for 22 Years
November 1, 2011 09:02 AM by Doug Powers
117 Comments
The Latest Dept of Energy Loan Recipient to Declare Bankruptcy Is…
October 31, 2011 02:00 PM by Doug Powers
75 Comments
Categories: fiscal stimulus
Professor Bob ‘Don’t Call Me Third’ Reich
You’re welcome.
Robert Reich, grow a thicker skin.
This guy is well overdue for the noogy ambulance, or, at least an atomic wedgie
Hmmm. A liberal academic who isn’t honest about his sources?
I wonder what he lied about in his PhD thesis?
I mean, do they really give those degrees to idiots?
Warning: This post contains sarcasm.
No one likes it when you can prove beyond any shadow of a doubt that they have no idea what they’re talking about.
Zippy. That’s a good nickname for the little guy.
Must.
Not.
Make.
Lollipop Guild.
Joke.
I’m still waiting for my construction job offer…I’m a woman & I wanna work outside.
Napoleonic complex meet the Big Dawgz of the blogosphere.
It’s a wild and wooly world out there, Lil Bobby.
Call your Mommy.
ROFLMAO
Reich: “Tell me about the bunny rabbits, George. I want to hold him and squeeze him and call him George………”
If plagiarism is ok for the VP, denying his own recorded words should be ok for this colostomy bag.
Translation from the Liberalese: I lied. So, what? I made my point and no-one will care that I lied.
Robert Reich attacks Will Farrell.
Colostomy bag works 2
RTater
He is an angry elf isn’t he???
LOL
Thanks, Socky!
Since liberal ideas don’t work very well, conservatives have to be silenced so that liberals don’t feel stupid. When the liberals cause the total colapse of this economy, it will be the conservatives who will rebuild it.
Boss, the plane, the plane!!!!
Bingo.
Fixed it.
Me too.
Yes.
I don’t see any.
Riech is a Communist. Read his early works and see for yourself.
We finally broke down and bought a flat panel HDTV (Super Bowl gift to/from me) and it is being delivered today. We are going from 32″ boobtube to 50″ boob tube. Will that make BobbyR look bigger or smaller? As it will be hooked up to my stereo will that whiny voice be more or less irritating?
Oh I wish I were better on this tech stuff. If I was I could fix my 8 track.
1% ers rock Rush.
What a wuss.
Just a reminder from the YouTube Link (below)that underscores Obama’s idea of “reparations/redistribution of wealth so
called jobs creation” Plan…? Rangle and Reich should finally motivate every American to call their local or DC Reps offices and express their opinions!
Finding a job in the coming years under the Obamalamadingdong Administation will be easy unless you are skilled, experienced, middle class (“not paying attention”)and white plus your Governor does not have a backbone! I am incensed! jb
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opxuUj6vFa4&e
Psst. Don’t tell anyone. I have an 8-track recorder from Panasonic. I am copying CD’s onto blank 8 track tapes so I can listen to them in my ’77 LTD. How dumb is that?
Reich might be the only three foot tall liberal in the world that looks down on half his country.
Imagine a tome co-authored by Robert Reich and Joe Biden. It would be an academic black hole – how do you misquote through plagiarizing?
Funny!
ArizonaNeandsaid:
‘…he knows changes aren’t permanent/but change is…’
How can he say it was taken out of context what he said about white men workers when it is right there on video(in color)for the whole world to see?
Because back in the day before internet, youtube, etc. this was the playbook for the left.
Looks like the democrats have already adopted Reich’s discriminatory approach to funding projects:
FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION HIGHWAY INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT Highway Infrastructure Investment Recovery Funding: $30 billion The Department of Transportation’s 2006 Conditions and Performance Report indicated there is an annual investment gap of $8.5 billion to maintain our current systems and an annual gap of $61.4 billion to improve highway and bridges. Furthermore, the recent report of the National Surface Transportation Policy and Revenue Study Commission recommended investing $225 billion annually from all sources over the next 50 years to maintain, upgrade, and expand our transportation networks. These funds will be used for ready-to-go, quick spending highway projects for which contracts can be awarded quickly. Twice last year, the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) surveyed State transportation departments and reported on the number and dollar value of additional highway projects that each State could undertake quickly if supplemental Federal funds were made available. The results of AASHTO’s December 2008 survey showed that all 50 States combined had over 5,100 projects totaling more than $64 billion that could be under contract within 180 days after enactment of Federal economic recovery legislation. These projects would include resurfacing and pavement preservation projects, traffic signal system upgrades, bridge projects, and intelligent transportation systems. Research indicates that highway investments deliver broad, substantial and lasting benefits to the economy. In the short term, money spent to improve and maintain highways supports private businesses with employment and the purchase of goods and services. Investments in the highway system provide benefits to commuters and travelers, including time savings, safety improvements, and vehicle operating cost reductions, and contributes to industry productivity growth, national economic performance, and international competitiveness. Funds are distributed by formula, with a portion of the funds within each State being suballocated by population areas. Set asides are also provided for: Indian reservation roads; park roads and parkways; on-the-training programs focused on minorities, women, and the socially and economically disadvantaged; a bonding assistance program for minority and disadvantaged businesses; and environmentally friendly transportation enhancements. According to the FHWA’s job model, this investment will create approximately 835,000 jobs across all sectors of the economy.
See: http://readthestimulus.org/index.php
Not dumb at all. Everyone knows that CD’s are just a fad. Analog all the way, baby!
Hmmm. That must be the book that BHO is carrying around! The old Democrat playbook!
You luddites still use CD’s?
Amplitude is the answer – nobody wants to be sampled and clipped
Well, I am still getting ~4.5% until the market returns to strength. Are you recommending any other financial instruments in the meantime?
Reich = Zippy
Zippy = Pinhead
Reich = Pinhead
Typical libtard, they dish it out, but can’t take it.
Professor Reich does not like to talk about his wife’s lawsuit against a prominent university that made her a rich woman. You can have lots of nice homes if you sue universities, scream about sexism and get the university to quietly surrender and toss in hundreds of thousands of dollars. Money that could have gone for scholarships for needy working class kids instead goes to a yuppie professor from Hades.
His students probably need to attend Special Ed classes after a semester with lying crackpot.
I suppose they have to get Lil Bobby Reich out to make Joe “Foot-in-Mouth” Biden look “more Vice Presidential.”