Rahm: Zoning rules for thee, but not for me
Report: Rahm Lives in Illegal Apartment.
$%^&*@!!!!
***
A reader absolves all-knowing, smarty-pants Rahm of any responsibility:
A clarification concerning your post on Emmanuel Rahm’s illegal basement apartment. (http://michellemalkin.com/2009/02/05/rahm-zoning-rules-for-thee-but-not-for-me/) It’s not the responsibility of the tenant to make sure that their home is properly zoned — it’s the responsibility of the landlord. So, your story should be aimed at Rep. DeLauro, not Rahm Emmanuel. He may not have known the status of the home he was living in, nor is there a legal requirement that he should. As a D.C. resident and renter myself, I know full well that many landlords do not have their homes properly zoned for rental purposes. A clarification is in order, don’t you think?
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Adventures in liberal tolerance, part 999,901
September 29, 2011 02:39 PM by Michelle Malkin
48 CommentsThe death threats that don’t make the nightly news
February 2, 2011 11:39 AM by Michelle Malkin
66 CommentsThe Philadelphia Horror: How mass murder gets a pass
January 21, 2011 12:00 AM by Michelle Malkin
131 CommentsLib radio talker attacks GOP Lt. Gov. of WI: She “performed fellatio on all the talk show hosts in Milwaukee” and “pulled a train”
January 20, 2011 12:10 PM by Michelle Malkin
165 CommentsCivility Watch: Nazis and crosshairs and killers, oh my; Update: Democrat Rep. Cohen doubles down on Nazi/KKK smears
January 19, 2011 03:35 PM by Michelle Malkin
89 CommentsIdiocracy: Conservatives who say “job-killing” are spreading hate
January 10, 2011 04:09 PM by Michelle Malkin
59 CommentsSelective ‘N-Word’ Outrage: William Morris Agency Dumps Mel Gibson
July 10, 2010 02:28 PM by Doug Powers
55 Comments
Categories: Double standards
Pundit & Pundette
» Bishop Jenky, Nicki Minaj, and the "98%"
Sister Toldjah
» Obama’s new budget is a bad joke



JustOneMinute
» We Hear From The Department Of Good Ideas And False Choices













***
Don’t cross RHAMBO. You could be hit with a “tour jete” kick, stabbed with a steak knife, and have your mailbox filled with dead fish!
***
Don’t pull on Superman’s cape. Don’t spit into the wind. Don’t pull the mask off the old Lone Ranger. And don’t mess around with RHAMBO!
***
John Bibb
***
What a surprise that he rents his illegal apartment from another Democrat politician.
/insert all the late night show jokes about living in a basement illegally
Didn’t Norm Coleman get skewered for this exact same thing?
I see the NY Times is all over this one. Oh, sorry. If it were Karl Rove, Newt, or, well, you know.I know I should not comment here … at least not in this way … but somehow the prospect of viewing these people as actual bottom-dwellers is just too good to pass up.
This seems like a good place to post something partially off-topic, but related to Rham:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/11057958/HR45-Blair-Holts-Firearm-Licensing-and-Record-of-Sale-Act-of-2009
Some highlights:
It shall be unlawful for any person other than a licensed importer, licensed manufacturer, licensed dealer, or licensed collector to possess a qualifying firearm on or after the applicable date, unless that person has been issued a firearm license
In order to be issued a firearm license under this title, an individual shall submit to the Attorney General…any mental health records pertaining to the applicant
Obama’s Number Two Lawyer at Justice is a porn-lovin’ pervert.
Shakespeare could not write such a story. This tragic-comedy could only happen in real life. Where’s the prop skull?
Something tells me the real issue is going to be the amount of rent being paid. Another sweetheart deal for a friend? Maybe some quid pro quo. I bet he pays a lot less than most in that area in similar apartments.
Sweetheart deals are just part of doing business when you are a Socialist Progressive Democrat.
I’m tired of the name games. Socialist is being worn with pride now. Time to call them what they are; Communists.
Actually, if you want to look at realities … the socialist programs combined with the nationalization of the economy and other nationalist programs.
Are you familiar with the term “Nationalist-Socialist” and what it is in German? Or at least the shortened version of it?
Honestly, I really think the blame should fall to the owner on this.
While I won’t quibble with you about this, Nazism was a form of Marixm. Had Hitler succeeded, you would have had a hard time distinguishing the resulting Europe from the USSR. But, to your point, I have no problem calling them Nazi.
Any bets that DeLauro didn’t claim the rent as income?
Well, not to put too fine a point on it, the Nazis were a socialist party but not all socialists are Marxists.
The term “Nazi” is derived from the German name of the party which was “Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei.” In English it is translated National Socialist German Workers Party. Socialist being a part of their perverse ideology.
The left desperately wants us to think the Nazis were a right-wing party. But the were lefties.
Ok is sweet – Rep. DeLauro claims she has never accepted any payment in the past six years for Rahm’s extended stay.
So, has he reported that as income on taxes?
Hitler was not personally a socialist. But he was quick to recognize that giving people things was the best way to coerce them.
He hated the Jews, while Progressives hate Christians.
I think the proper term for national socialism in Germany some while back was “Nationalische Socialistiche Deutsche Arbeiter Partie”. Or something close to that. NSDAP were the initials.
Or, as it was more widely known, NAZI.
Some weirdo in a tiny dorky mustache ran it.
Careful there… even porn-lovin’ perverts need (self)love too
Seriously? A post about Rahm’s illegal apartment has turned into a discussion on the origins of the Nazi party?
If she is giving the living space away, she is stupid, but I don’t think he or she should be taxed on it. Just my opinion.
Actually, my main point was the reflection that is going on here … calling us to task and accusing us on the right of doing what they are already doing … so as to effectively negate our argument before we have an opportunity to present it in an unbiased and open forum. Still, it does bring up some interesting (and frightening) insight into exactly how people like Hitler got into power under the nose of the German people … and hopefully enough people will remember their history to prevent it from happening here … but I have to say that it does not look good for the home team.
As a person who has both written and enforced zoning laws, the spite should go out to Rep. DeLauro. It is the affirmative obligation for a property owner to know the permitted uses and limitations of a property, and to obey the law. Property owners get nailed for that failure all the time.
Practically, and under normal circumstances, the FMV of the rental could probably be covered by the annual exclusion for gift tax ($13,000 yr/ per donee, with spousal gift splitting that is $26,000 a year), such that it would not be income, and no one has any tax consequences. But of course it is complicated by the whole Congressman thing which imposes its own restrictions.
When it comes to basement apartments in DC, no they don’t. Everyone and their mother rents out basement apartments.
I wonder who is footing the bill for the PI to go dig up dirt on Rahm.
I have to agree with the “reader.” As a land use attorney, I work with zoning and variances in California. The owner is responsible for knowing what is permitted use on his property.
While it is possible for a renter to determine if his use is permitted, it is unlikely that any renter would do so.
Morally I see this in another way. My sister in law and son are staying with us taking up 2 rooms and not paying rent because she is unemployed and pregnant. (try finding a job while pregnant) anyway, should one of us be taxed in some way? I don’t think so. They are my rooms to invite whomever I want. If I decide to let someone stay there vs leaving the rooms empty, is that any business of the governments? Now the code violations are all on the owner. But rahm should at least offer to help pay to fix the issue. Moraly speaking of course.
To Sonofdy:
The reason for the zoning is to prevent someone from renting out their house to a ton of people. Radio Talkhosts “John and Ken” on 640 KFI in California refer to these houses as “clown houses” where you have entire families living in a single room.
Personally, I think Michelle is making a mountain out of a molehill on this. Such violations occur all the time and no one makes a big deal about them. You just get the problem fixed. Hell, usually, no one even bother reporting the issue except for busybodies.
Ok, I challenge you to rent even a simple one bedroom apartment in DC for less than $2000 per month. In that neighborhood, he went over the gift allowance.
Seeing as I am actually currently looking at apartments in DC at this very moment, I can assure you that, for a basement apartment on Capitol Hill, $2,000/month is very very doable.
Look what we have today, some weirdo with big dorky ears running it.
Well, you guys are the big tax lovers, not me. So I am actually using liberal logic when I say yes – - they should be taxed on the fair rental value of the room, although because she is family there would probably be an exemption.
Churches allow ministers to live on their private property, and the minister has to report a fair rental value for SS purposes. Why can’t he just stay for free, if private property is the determining factor?
For example…
Basement living, huh?
Suits him, that damn troll!
Resign, Rahm!
Coleman was paying $600 for a 10 x 10 room.
The Democrats cried this was far below fair market value.
http://www.nationaljournal.com/njonline/no_20080701_7046.php
I can pull up rent.com listings for $4395 for a 2 bedroom basement apartment in DC. Which do you think Rahm would settle for – low end or high end?
The basement is where rats belong.
The basement is where the vampire was kept in Salem’s Lot.
Why isn’t DeLauro running a brothel in the basement like any other self-
respectingabsorbed Congressperson?Not impossible but it is very difficult to kill yourself jumping out of a basement window. So that’s one good thing.
The Dems were probably wrong if he just had a bedroom and bathroom. But also, the rental market thankfully is far different now.
And just because some crack smoker thinks they can get $4400 for a two bedroom BASEMENT apartment, does not set the market value. And FYI, the one I cited was above many of the other listings I saw.
Somehow, the image of him crawling out of a underground lair every morning seems natural.
On Capitol Hill, the preferred method of suicide for basement dwellers is to leave the ground level window open, loudly brag about all the Benjamins you have stashed in your mattress, and calmly wait for someone to break in, rob and kill you.
No way – DC is gentrified. Burglers now put everything back in place. It’s quite livable now.
I thought shooting yourself in the back of the head with a shotgun and leaving the gun in a separate room was the preferred method? Not to be morbid but …
I used to work near Union Station and Capitol Hill is not as gentrified and crime-free as many think.
There are frequent robberies and other violent crimes on the hill and it often involves a member of congress or a staffer.
And I am pretty sure $1825 for the apartment Chap found is a STEAL. I suspect it is gone already.
I was talking about Democratic House members.
I didn’t read the background article, but is Rahm’s landlord paying income taxes on the rent? HAHA, bet not. Apparently Dems in the gubmint don’t pay taxes!!
Chap,
I believe you were misinformed. Dems keep their “Benjamins” in their freezers. Also, there is no need to fear being shot while being robbed. They banned firearms in DC so they no longer exist there.
Has anyone here checked the zoning ordinances before renting an apartment(especially temporary housing)? It’s fairly common practice to do so before you buy (in fact EVERYONE should) but renting is a much different story. I guess it’s a slow day.
As a dyed-in-the-wool ultra conservative I think the burden for renting the apartment is on the owner and not the tenant.
That said, it is possible Rep. DeLauro and Rahm Emmanuel were violating some ethics and income tax rules. And we wouldn’t have bothered to look had this zoning issue not come up.
Even an evil, radical leftist like Emmanuel will sometimes NOT break a law. It is sort of like a stopped watching being “right” two times a day.
As a staunch Conservative, I will admit that I was wrong. Although accepting gifts is a violation of Washington ethics clauses, income taxes on gifts over the threshold is payable by the gifter.
So DeLauro is the tax dodger in this instance.
Follow the link to the original story on Gawker and read the comments. I don’t know if they are from men or women, but apparently Rhambo is viewed as a stud and there is a waiting line outside the basement.