So much for the most deliberative body in the world
A Senate staffer sends the following info to illuminate how the most deliberative body in the world is short-circuiting debate on the Generational Theft Act of 2009.
I repeat what Sen. Coburn said on the Senate floor: “Hurry up is what got us into trouble in the first place.”
I repeat: Kill the bill. Stab it. Stick a fork in it. Then start from scratch (and leave out the godawful mortgage entitlement amendment, please!)
***
From Senate staffer…
Just to give everyone a snapshot of the real debate that has occurred on the largest spending bill in history, as of 2pm today:
* 315 amendments have been filed
* 20 amendments have been considered
* 9 amendments have been adopted
* 11 amendments were rejected
* 14 are currently pending
This is a 736 page senate bill, rushed through committee with no hearings, and could pass after being on the floor for less than one week.
Based on where we are today, about 90% of the more than 300 amendments have not received consideration.
Here are the only 9 amendments that have been adopted:
Dorgan Amdt #300
To clarify that the Buy American provisions shall be applied in a manner consistent with United States obligations under international agreements.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 8:31 PM, 02.04.2009
Cardin Amdt #237
To amend certain provisions of the Small Business Investment Act of 1958, related to the surety bond guarantee program.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 6:24 PM, 02.04.2009
Harkin Amdt #178
To provide an additional $6,500,000,000 to the National Institutes of Health for biomedical research.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 8:55 PM, 02.03.2009
Bond Amdt #161
To provide $2,000,000,000 from the HOME program for investment in the low income housing tax credit projects.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 7:22 PM, 02.04.2009
Murray Amdt #110
To strengthen the infrastructure investments made by the bill.
AGREED TO RECORD VOTE at 1:00 PM, 02.03.2009
Coburn Amdt #109
To strike the $246 million tax earmark for Hollywood production companies.
AGREED TO RECORD VOTE at 4:54 PM, 02.03.2009
Isakson Amdt #106
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide a Federal income tax credit for certain home purchases.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 6:24 PM, 02.04.2009
Mikulski Amdt #104
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to allow an above-the-line deduction against individual income tax for interest on indebtedness and for State sales and excise taxes with respect to the purchase of certain motor vehicles.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 5:14 PM, 02.03.2009
Landrieu Amdt #102
To ensure that assistance for the redevelopment of foreclosed and abandoned homes to States or units of local government impacted by catastrophic natural disasters may be used to support the redevelopment of homes damaged or destroyed as a result of the 2005 hurricanes, the severe flooding in the Midwest in 2008, and other natural disasters.
AGREED TO UNANIMOUS CONSENT at 10:30 PM, 02.04.2009
Here are the 11 amendments that have been rejected:
Martinez Amdt #159
To reduce home foreclosures, compensate servicers who modify mortgages, and remove the legal constraints that inhibit modification, and for other purposes.
WITHDRAWN UNANIMOUS CONSENT at 7:01 PM, 02.04.2009
Specter Amdt #101
To provide an additional $6,500,000,000 to the National Institutes of Health for biomedical research.
WITHDRAWN UNANIMOUS CONSENT at 8:55 PM, 02.03.2009
McCain Amdt #278
To reimplement Gramm-Rudman-Hollings to require deficit reduction and spending cuts upon 2 consecutive quarters of positive GDP growth.
RULED OUT OF ORDER at 7:22 PM, 02.04.2009
Cornyn Amdt #277
To reduce income taxes for all working taxpayers.
RULED OUT OF ORDER at 8:25 PM, 02.04.2009
Inhofe Amdt #262
To appropriate, with an offset, $5,232,000,000 for procurement for the Department of Defense to reconstitute military units to an acceptable readiness rating and to restock prepositioned assets and war reserve material.
RULED OUT OF ORDER at 7:44 PM, 02.04.2009
Bunning Amdt #242
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to suspend for 2009 the 1993 income tax increase on Social Security benefits, and for other purposes.
RULED OUT OF ORDER at 8:31 PM, 02.04.2009
DeMint Amdt #168
In the nature of a substitute.
RULED OUT OF ORDER at 6:41 PM, 02.04.2009
Boxer Amdt #112
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to allow the deduction for dividends received from controlled foreign corporations for an additional year, and for other purposes.
RULED OUT OF ORDER at 8:55 PM, 02.03.2009
McCain Amdt #279
To prohibit the applicability of Buy American requirements in the Act to the utilization of funds provided by the Act.
NOT AGREED TO RECORD VOTE at 8:52 PM, 02.04.2009
Thune Amdt #238
To ensure that the $1 trillion spending bill is not used to expand the scope of the Federal Government by adding new spending programs.
NOT AGREED TO RECORD VOTE at 7:01 PM, 02.04.2009
Vitter Amdt #179
To eliminate unnecessary spending.
NOT AGREED TO RECORD VOTE at 6:24 PM, 02.04.2009
Here are the 14 amendments currently pending:
McCain Amdt #364
In the nature of a substitute.
Boxer Amdt #363
To ensure that any action taken under this act of any funds made available under this act that are subject to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) protect the public health of communities across the country.
Dodd Amdt #354
To impose executive compensation limitations with respect to entities assisted under the Troubled Asset Relief Program.
Ensign Amdt #353
In the nature of a substitute.
Harkin Amdt #338
To require the Secretary of the Treasury to carry out a program to enable certain individuals to trade certain automobiles for certain new automobiles.
Barrasso Amdt #326
To expedite reviews required to be carried out under the National Environment Policy Act of 1969.
McCaskill Amdt #236
To establish funding levels for various offices of inspectors general and to set a date until which such funds shall remain available.
Dorgan Amdt #200
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide for the taxation of income of controlled foreign corporations attributable to imported property.
Thune Amdt #197
In the nature of a substitute.
DeMint Amdt #189
To allow the free exercise of religion at institutions of higher education that receive funding under section 803 of division A.
Dodd Amdt #145
To improve the efforts of the Federal Government in mitigating home foreclosures and to require the Secretary of the Treasury to develop and implement a foreclosure prevention loan modification plan.
Feingold Amdt #140
To provide greater accountability of taxpayers’ dollars by curtailing congressional earmarking and requiring disclosure of lobbying by recipients of Federal funds.
McCaskill Amdt #125
To limit compensation to officers and directors of entities receiving emergency economic assistance from the Government.
Inouye Amdt #98
In the nature of a substitute.
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Trackbacks
- Fiscal Suicide: Dr. Coburn’s Got the Cure « JoHNBRoDiGaNDoTCoM
- Wizbang
- Harry Reid getting desperate - Political Wrinkles
- So much for the most deliberative body in the world — But As For Me
- Taeda Inflammus » Blog Archive » Igneous Taeda - 004 - Rock, Rock, Rock and Roll Congress
- There's My Two Cents
- Liberalism and Mischief « Rantings of mine
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Categories: fiscal stimulus
Power Line
» More From the East Anglia Archives

American Thinker
» Sarah Palin and the low ebb of the cultural left
Doug Ross @ Journal
» ACORN pwnage part II: Breitbart's BigGovt Lowers the Boom
Big Government
» BREAKING: San Diego ACORN Document Dump Scandal
Villainous Company
» Amateur Hour in the Oval Office Continues....
Nice Deb
» O
Green Room
» Times Slimes Obamic Climes










You thinik Odrama is figuring out he’s not in Chicago anymore? He can’t circumvent all the rules now. He doesn’t get to use all the pay-to-play options. Or maybe he is just now figuring out the answer to every tough question can no longer be “It’s George Bush’s fault”.
You’re not on the campaign trail anymore The One. The media love fest is starting to slow and it’s washing away your glow.
Gods mercy what I would give for a Constitutional amendment that required all bills to be “clean” bills. As well as a sunset clause on all bills other than tax cuts.
A question that far too few people seem interested in asking is “how can these people pass any legislation that they haven’t fully read?”. This may be a big, obvious example of it but the practice seems horrifyingly common in both houses of congress.
How about “We the People” say:
The Democratic Socialist “leadership” in Washington, D.C.
(including Obama, Reid, Pelosi, and others) is
sonofdy Amdt #798
A one time payment to Michelle Malkin of 1 million dollars and to each of her registered posters of 1 million dollars as long as they are registered as of 02/04/2009.
Reading is for the little people.
They do not care about passing legislation that they have read … as they do not have the time to read it and by re-electing these … ummmmm … people all the time, they have no cause to read them even if they wanted to. Until we hold their collective political feet to the fire they will continue to act in such a manner. Given the level of political apathy and the freedom which we allow dead people, illegal aliens and others to vote … well the future does not look bright enough for even a cheap pair of sunglasses.
AGREED TO VOICE VOTE at 2:58 PM, 02.05.2009
Willfully ignorant political leaders entrenched in power are a curse on any nation.
As I said earlier: Congress should adjourn for two full years and give the national economy the time to heal itself. We don’t need any more governmental “help” for the time being. The longer the government meddles in this crisis, the longer and deeper it will last. The only positive action they can take at this point is to radically reduce taxes and spending – something they are apparently incapable of.
Aye! The Aye’s have it. Yipppeeee!
Hell, they didn’t read the articles of impeachment against Bill Clinton, why should they read the bill that’s supposed to “Save Our Economy”?
I guess this would mean that it would take at least one year before any new infrastructure projects could break ground. Stimulus my eye.
***
I keep thinking that it would have been a lot better for the American People if the fourth plane hijacked on 9/11/2001 had made it to its intended target–the Capitol Building–when the full House and Senate were in session.
***
A bad thought for a Christian–but all we get from our “representatives” is more theft and corruption.
***
That would have been term limits you could believe in. Our government makeup would be a lot different now. Maybe the Devil prevented that last plane from hitting the building. Our present Congress serves him better than it serves us.
***
John Bibb
***
I’ll take mine in gold coins, please (no paper money for me!).
The Democrats favorite ploy. Give the voters all the pork they want. Kick the can down the road and when the irresponsible legislation catches up and the consequences become known, blame the Republicans for the mess. It’s as cyclical as the seasons (if you live in temperate climates where seasons actually do exist).
Remember when Obama said we need to use a scalpel not a hatchet when dealing with the budget? Turns out he was referring to implants.
First Senator Grahamnesty criticizes Obama’s porkulus bill, now Juan McCain tries to introduce a conservative amendment to the rotting corpse, what is this world comng to?
This is prime example why we need to march on D.C. and run these so called leaders out of OUR government. We need to take back our country and put people in place that realize they work for US (WE THE PEOPLE) not special interest. How can they be so stupid as to see the crap they rushed through last year is not working only to rush to do more of the same stupid stuff.
I call for a revolution. Our founding fathers knew this day would come and gave us away to make sure we where able to take back control. If they pass this we will never be able to look our kids or grandkids in the face and beleive in our hearts we where doing what was best for them.
On February 5th, 2009 at 2:42 pm, James Felix said:
I agree.
I’ve seen two good suggestions on this topic…either:
1) Prohibit bills that are any longer than the Constitution itself.
2) Require all bills to be read out loud, word for word, in each chamber respectively, before that chamber can vote on the bill.
That would put an end to votes on 736 page bills, period.
Instead, they exist and are rushed through committee with no hearings, and could pass after being on the floor for less than one week.
The Congress members voting on this have most likely not read the bill, and don’t know the “unintended consequences” that await.
Have you ever stopped to think about who WROTE this 736 page bill?
I say that the writing of this bill was not rushed…the authors have had written up exactly what they want for some time now, just waiting for the right opportunity to “cut and paste” what they want into a bill that won’t be read before it is voted on. I believe that was also the case with the “bailout” that was pushed in September.
The Socialists know what they want, and they are using pressure tactics to push it through without debate.
This is not “Change we can believe in”. This is business as usual for the Democratic Socialists.
Real change in Washington would come in the form of people like Mike Huckabee and Sarah Palin.
So glad to be a registered member.
They never read anything. they have paid associates that give them the “gist” of each bill, and then they look at the polls and vote accordingly.
There is not a soul in Congress with a single ouce of ethics. They say what needs to be said to get elected and then vote just to stay in power.
Is there any doubt that if the polls were going in favor of this debacle that it would not pass 100%, regardless of the horrendous, irrepairable destruction it will do to this nation and it’s economy?
The population of this country are incredibly ignorant of anything having to do with this “stimulus” package, let alone the problems facing the nation on a whole, otherwise they never would have voted the buffoon into office in the first place.
The only the thing they are deliberate about is looking out for themselves.
It’s pitchfork time!
ok let me get this straight…. they vote down working on reducing the deficit, on cutting goverment spending on earmarks and giving working Americans a tax cut. THE HYPOCRISY OF THIS REALLY REALLY PISSES ME OFF! Anyone from Indiana want to take a trip to D.C. to protest?
Hey, you lazy DC Democrats I think you guys are missing the big picture here.
Don’t just socialize America socialize the entire galaxy. Why stop at $1 trillion, when you can build and launch your own Death Star for $15 septillion. You can help Iran keep their Mohamed satellite up and nuke every red state and free thinking nation or planet from orbit.
Im in, Right after I get the cash from the sonofdy amendment.
gots to get me an ar-15….
You can have your AR15/M16. I still prefer the M14 waaaaaaaaaaaaay more.
“I’m out of order? You’re out of order! The whole trial is out of order! They’re out of order!”
–Al Pacino, And Justice For All
And yet the only worthwhile amendment I can think of cannot even be debated!!!
http://www.numbersusa.com/content/news/february-4-2009/crucial-day-e-verify-amendments-senate.html
I believe any US Senator can request the chair to read the entire bill in its entirety.
I could be wrong, but I think it was one of the things McConnell did to Reid last November or December to show displeasure on the slow pace of getting Bush’s judges out of committee for floor votes.
If that is indeed possible, someone needs to do it, and fast.
Obama has sold every last one in America and there is a waiting list – which Holder probably has right now.
WTH?!?! Does this mean that certain individuals cannot currently trade certain automobiles for certain new automobiles? Who knew?!?!
This whole thing pisses me off more every day. I love the idea of forcing the bill to be read out loud. Can we start a petition to force that??
Got one last week while I was home. Carbine version. For 200 less than MSRP.
It’s ammo I am having trouble finding.
If the Garand can defeat Nazis…
First, don’t give them any ideas.
Second, I think the numbers are wrong. The first Death Star was built with droid labor as well as a huge amount of slave labor. Both Wookie slaves and inmates from the prison planet Despayre. (Which was coincidentally the first test bed for the superlaser on the Death Star.)
The slave labor alone would have knocked off at least a million. Sheesh.
It doesn’t matter. All they are doing is printing the money they want now. What makes you think they aren’t planning on getting this thing muscled through, nationalizing the banks and then printing all the money in the world they want?
If you haven’t read the article in Salon today, they are already saying how the 70’s were a wonderland, and it is the Reagan/Republican Revolution of the last 30 years that is to blame, and nothing else.
They merely want to return to those “Glory Days of Yester-year”, only this time, making the Socialist improvements that Carter and the Dems of that time were too scared to make.
*The bill will pass, there is no getting around that; There are enough traitors to the constitution in both parties to do this dirty deed and 2010 may be too late to reverse the tide, so may I suggest, IMPEACH P-BO NOW!
How do we organize a march on the Capitol? The time is here and now that the people take our country back from these idiots. I have such a sick feeling in my stomach that I could throw up. And just chatting about it on here isn’t going to do anything; it’s time to act! They seem to ignore phone calls and emails, but they can’t ignore throngs of angry Americans on the steps. Name the time and spread the message far and wide and I’ll be there.
Certain Individuals = Liberals
Certain Automobiles = 1980 and older
Certain NEW Automobiles =Jaguar,Ferrari,
Jefferson, Churchill, and Reagan must be rolling over in their graves about now:
The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of the blessings. The inherent blessing of socialism is the equal sharing of misery. — Sir Winston Churchill
A wise and frugal government, which shall leave men free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor and bread it has earned–this is the sum of good government. — Thomas Jefferson
Government’s view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it. — Ronald Reagan
I’m in
That would be something worth coming back to the states for if only I could afford it. Maybe if I pose as an illegal alien I can get free passage or someone to subsidize my trip?
ROFL!
I believe any Senator can request a reading of the bill in consideration.
But I’m not sure.
I’m an engineer, not a lawyer.
I don’t believe it – something I think I agree with Russ Feingold on:
Feingold Amdt #140
To provide greater accountability of taxpayers’ dollars by curtailing congressional earmarking and requiring disclosure of lobbying by recipients of Federal funds.
I would like to have mine paid in Interns…. since Im getting screwed in this whole deal anyway, I might as well have someone to handle the ‘paperwork’ for me.
I misread the headline. I thought it read the most “debilitated” body in the world.
Wait…
pork = bribes for people who vote but don’t pay taxes.
The vision of Americans and strong and independent people is quickly fading into the past. Too many people are ignorant of history and the Constitution and want something for nothing.
My eldest son (22) asked me how we could reverse the socialism we’re headed towards. I told him that we would have to have a revolution, there would be no other way to wrest power from the socialists.
I saw a fraud alert story on TV yesterday,a woman had her CC info nabbed by a phony auto warranty renewal call. According to an expert,
one of the tips that it was fraud was the hook of urgency -”you must decide right NOW to receive this great deal”.
Then today the President says- If you don’t pass this NOW,we may NEVER recover.
Scam artists come in all sizes.
Porkulus, Spendulous, Scamulus, it must die.
Hoo-boy! This is why they say that sausage and legislation are two things you don’t want to see while they’re being made. Trouble is, we really NEED to see what’s going on with this legislation. Thank you, MM and others who are giving us the specifics.
Would any level-headed person buy a home, car, jewelry, TV, WHATEVER without understanding exactly what it is they are getting?
I guess Congress doesn’t have to read what they vote for or against, because they aren’t paying for it, we are.