To GIVE and to SERVE: the $6 billion National Service boondoggle

By Michelle Malkin  •  March 25, 2009 09:50 AM

My syndicated column today looks at the massive expansion of government-funded “national service.” Debate began yesterday in the Senate, where the $6 billion SERVE Act’s primary co-sponsors are Sens. Ted Kennedy and…Orrin Hatch. And there’s the rub. Since its inception, AmeriCorps has been a bipartisan-supported beast. The Evil Party and the Stupid Party strike again. If this does lead to the establishment of a civilian national security force, as Obama signaled during the campaign, Republicans who vote for this Trojan Horse will have no one to blame but themselves.

***

To GIVE and to SERVE: The $6 billion National Service boondoggle
by Michelle Malkin
Creators Syndicate
Copyright 2009

Maybe it’s just me, but I find federal legislation titled “The GIVE Act” and “The SERVE Act” downright creepy. Even more troubling: The $6 billion price tag on these bipartisan bills to expand government-funded national service efforts. Volunteerism is a wonderful thing, which is why millions of Americans do it every day without a cent of taxpayer money. But the volunteerism packages on the Hill are less about promoting effective charity than about creating make-work, permanent bureaucracies, and left-wing slush funds.

The House passed the “Generations Invigorating Volunteerism and Education Act” – or the GIVE Act – last week. The Senate took up the companion “SERVE Act” Tuesday afternoon. According to a Congressional Budget Office analysis of the Senate bill, S. 277, the bill would cost “$418 million in 2010 and about $5.7 billion over the 2010-2014 period.” And like most federal programs, these would be sure to grow over time. The bills reauthorize the Clinton-era Americorps boondoggle program and an older law, the Domestic Volunteer Service Act of 1973.

The programs have already been allocated $1.1 billion for fiscal 2009, including $200 million from the porkulus package signed into law last month. In addition to recruiting up to 250,000 enrollees in AmeriCorps, the GIVE/SERVE bills would create new little armies of government volunteers, including a Clean Energy Corps, Education Corps, Healthy Futures Corps, Veterans Service Corps, and and expanded National Civilian Community Corps for disaster relief and energy conservation. And that’s not all. Spending would include new funds for:

*Foster Grandparent Program ($115 million);

*Learn and Serve America. ($97 million);

*Retired and Senior Volunteer Program ($70 million);

*Senior Companion Program ($55 million);

*$12 million for each of fiscal years 2010 through 2014 for “the Silver Scholarships and Encore Fellowships programs;”

*$10 million a year from 2010-2014 for a new “Volunteers for Prosperity” program at USAID to “award grants to fund opportunities for volunteering internationally

in coordination with eligible organizations; and

*Social Innovation Fund and Volunteer Generation Fund-$50 million in 2010; $60 million in 2011; $70 million in 2012; $80 million in 2013; and $100 million in 2014.

“Social Innovation Fund?” If that sounds familiar, it should. I reported last fall on the Democratic Party platform’s push to fund a “Social Investment Fund Network” that would reward “social entrepreneurs and leading nonprofit organizations” and “support results-oriented innovators.” It is essentially a special taxpayer-funded pipeline for radical liberal groups backed by billionaire George Soros that masquerade as public-interest do-gooders.

Especially troublesome to parents’ groups concerned about compulsory volunteerism requirements is a provision in the House version, directing Congress to explore “whether a workable, fair, and reasonable mandatory service requirement for all able young people could be developed, and how such a requirement could be implemented in a manner that would strengthen the social fabric of the Nation and overcome civic challenges by bringing together people from diverse economic, ethnic, and educational backgrounds.”

Those who have watched AmeriCorps from its inception are all-too-familiar with how government voluntarism programs have been used for propaganda and political purposes. AmeriCorps “volunteers” have been put to work lobbying against the voter-approved three-strikes anti-crime initiative in California and protesting Republican political events while working for the already heavily-tax-subsidized liberal advocacy group ACORN.

Citizens Against Government Waste, the D.C. watchdog, also documented national service volunteers lobbying for rent control, expanded federal housing subsidies, and enrollment of more women in the Women, Infants, and Children welfare program. AmeriCorps volunteers have also been paid to shuffle paper at the Department of Justice, the Department of Interior, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Legal Services Corporation, and the National Endowment for the Arts.

(Now, imagine Obama’s troops being sent overseas – out of sight and unaccountable — as part of that $10 million a year USAID/”Volunteers for Prosperity” program. Egad.)

One vigilant House member, GOP Rep. Virginia Foxx, successfully attached an amendment to the GIVE Act to bar National Service recipients from engaging in political lobbying, endorsing or opposing legislation, organizing petitions, protests, boycotts, or strikes; providing or promoting abortions or referrals; or influencing union organizing.

Supporters of GIVE/SERVE are now fighting those restrictions tooth and nail, screaming censorship and demanding that the provisions be dropped. Which tells you everything you need to know about the true nature of this boondoggle: Taxpayers GIVE their money to SERVE a big government agenda under the guise of helping their fellow man. It’s charity at the point of a gun.

***

Don’t know why, but the creepy title of the Senate bill reminds me of that classic Twilight Zone episode, “To Serve Man.” Remember?

See what others have said

Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.

Trackbacks

  1. Aside from the Echoes of Fascism, There Are Other Problems with Chairman Zero’s “Obama Youth” Scheme « Teh Resistance Blog
  2. Thou Shalt Have No Other Gods Before Him [Dan Collins]
  3. Federal Government Paying “Volunteers” To Teach Liberal Values « Peace and Freedom Global Future
  4. Can you imagine if Obama said his bowling score was like the “guys”(terrorists) at Gitmo? « Jim Blazsik
  5. Brownshirts, Anyone? « Patriot Burr
  6. Hot Air » Blog Archive » GIVE … until it’s mandatory?
  7. Obama’s Policies Are “A Road to Hell,” European Leader Says | OpenMarket.org
  8. Hitler Youth Program coming to an American town near you soon « Sharp Right Turn
  9. Reinstituting The Draft « Justbkuz
  10. To GIVE and to SERVE: the $6 billion National Service boondoggle « Thoughts Of A Conservative Christian
  11. Michelle Malkin » Roll call vote on $6 billion national service boondoggle: 14 GOP dissenters
  12. Obama Seeks Expanded Power to Take Other People’s Stuff « Designated Conservative
  13. “…young people will be forced to participate in mandatory national service programs.” « Gunservatively!
  14. Gazzer’s Gabfest » Blog Archive » Oxymoronic Gubmint, without the oxy part…
  15. Is the goal of GIVE/SERVE Act increasing volunteerism or generational indoctrination? | Unequal Time
  16. We ‘GIVE’ the government another $6 billion boondoggle / The Government ‘SERVES’ itself | Fire Andrea Mitchell!
  17. Got milk? « poplicola
  18. America’s Survival Is In Your Hands | Hennessy's View
  19. GIVE, SERVE, LIVE, LOVE, PI PHI…wait. Congress is pushing it.
  20. Memo to Obama: Forced Giving Isn’t Actually “Giving” | You Decide Politics
  21. National Service - To GiVE and to SERVE | The Lonely Conservative
  22. To GIVE and to SERVE: the $6 billion National Service boondoggle « Random Thoughts
  23. Conservative Nation » Obama’s Amerika - Links for 3/25/2009
  24. Are Republicans Stupid?
  25. Liberty and Tyranny: A Conservative Manifesto | Political Crave
  26. Community Service Bill Marginalizes Organized Religion | Axis of Right
  27. Could this story be true: Mandatory Community Service « Dianej’s Weblog
  28. Cutting More Jobs, Shifting Work to India « Goodtimepolitics
  29. Cash Is King And Obama Is Not |
  30. Republicans AWOL On Obama’s Expanded Americorps « Nice Deb
  31. To Serve Man, You Must Obey | Mothers Against Govt Intervention & Control
  32. southchild » Blog Archive » Sen. DeMint: An “Intervention” is needed in Georgia
  33. Liberty Waning » Sen. DeMint: An “Intervention” is needed in Georgia
  34. To GIVE and to SERVE: the $6 billion National Service boondoggle « ACGR’s “News with Attitude”
  35. Michelle Malkin » GIVE/SERVE Act updates
  36. Hot Air » Blog Archive » Glenn Beck to Michelle: Are you worried about Obama’s mandatory volunteerism plan?
  37. Hot Air » Blog Archive » Glenn Beck to Michelle: Are you worried about Obama’s mandatory volunteerism plan?
  38. “GIVE/SERVE Act Updates” « Patriot Burr
  39. Mandatory Service Requirements for Youth
  40. Obama’s FORCED VOLUNTEERING: Approved! « FactReal
  41. To GIVE and to SERVE - It Passes | Radio Vice Online
  42. Is Obama’s mandatory ‘voluntary’ public service corps the slippery slope to the Weathermen’s vision of re-education death camps? — Cynthia Yockey
  43. Six Meat Buffet » Blog Archive » Senator Alexander Wants You To Give/Serve!
  44. Michelle Malkin » Hatch dedicates $6 billion GIVE/SERVE boondoggle to Kennedy; plus: mandatory service study lives!
  45. A Recovery Party? Random Chills, Thrills & Myths | The Anchoress
  46. Joke of the day: How many Useful Idiots does it take to screw in a Compact Fluorescent lightbulb? « Danishova
  47. The Two Malcontents » Congress Contemplates Mandatory ‘Voluntary’ Service
  48. Michelle Malkin » To GIVE and to SERVE | justapipe.com
  49. Capital Research Center:
  50. The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Democrats Kill Provision in AmeriCorps Bill that Would Keep Funds from ACORN
  51. Girls - How SMART are we? - Smart Girl Nation
  52. SUV’s for me . . . but not for thee. - Smart Girl Nation
  53. Michelle Malkin » Get ready for the anti-Tea Party sabotage and smear campaign
  54. The Liberty Papers »Blog Archive » Action item for libertarians and small-government conservatives
  55. Bachmann: The Serve America Act will lead to ‘re-education camps for young people.’ | Dailycensored.com
  56. Action item for libertarians and small-government conservatives | Politics News
  57. Girls….how SMART are we? - Smart Girl Nation
  58. Michelle Malkin » An Army of Tax Revolters — and a warning to fair-weather Republicans
  59. Obama's Youth? - Ajarn Forum - Living and Teaching In Thailand
  60. The Unintended Consequences of Senator Hatch’s Missionary Experience « Designated Conservative
  61. Give Back: First Lady Michelle Obama’s UC Merced Graduation Message « Frugal Café Blog Zone
  62. Michelle Malkin » The biggest, most magical makework program ever!
  63. Michelle Malkin » The biggest, most magical makework program ever!
  64. Michelle Malkin » The biggest, most magical makework program ever!
  65. Michelle Malkin » Obama’s Americorps scandal — and the First Lady’s meddling
  66. Still More Thug Politics: Obama Fires AmeriCorps IG Who Identified Millions In Misspent Money « Nice Deb
  67. http://michellemalkin.com/2009/06/12/obamas-americorps-scandal-and-the-first-ladys-me - Jesse's Hunting & Outdoors Forum
  68. A Small Corner of Sanity - An Online Oasis for Conservative Thought
  69. Obama’s Americorps scandal — and the First Lady’s meddling « Thoughts Of A Conservative Christian
  70. President Obama Fires Inspector General Gerald Walpin–Teapot Scandle Slowly Simmers! « Pronk Palisades
  71. Another Budget Destroyed: Michelle Obama, UC Merced, and a Whopping Million Dollars « Frugal Café Blog Zone
  72. Bachmann’s Son Joins AmeriCorps Program, Which She Once Called A ‘Re-education Camp’ Unfit For Her Kids : Dailycensored.com
  73. Michelle Malkin » Look who’s hijacking 9/11
  74. September 11 Falls On A Friday This Year « Around The Sphere
  75. ‘I Participate’

Trackback URL

Comments


  1. #787612
    On August 24th, 2009 at 1:26 pm, ITookTheRedPill said:

    One vigilant House member, GOP Rep. Virginia Foxx, successfully attached an amendment to the GIVE Act to bar National Service recipients from engaging in political lobbying, endorsing or opposing legislation, organizing petitions, protests, boycotts, or strikes; providing or promoting abortions or referrals; or influencing union organizing.

    GOP Rep. Virginia Foxx is one of the best there is in Congress!

    Congresswoman Foxx doesn’t get much credit for it, but she was one of the handful of Republicans (including Hoekstra, Culberson, Pence, Shadegg, and other GOP House revolutionaries) who stood their ground and started the first “Tea Party” last August when Nancy Pelosi moved to shut down the House and silence their revolt.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Doing the digging the dinosaur media won’t do

November 23, 2009 02:35 PM by Michelle Malkin

31 Comments | 2 Trackbacks

Emetic of the day

November 19, 2009 01:14 PM by Michelle Malkin

93 Comments | 2 Trackbacks

“You guys make a pretty good photo op.”

SEIU thugs lash back over Boy Scout debacle

November 19, 2009 10:59 AM by Michelle Malkin

47 Comments | 0 Trackbacks

How do you say “You lie!” in Mandarin?

November 18, 2009 09:20 AM by Michelle Malkin

85 Comments | 12 Trackbacks

Obama’s double-talk on dissent.

Cartoon of the day

November 16, 2009 10:21 PM by Michelle Malkin

58 Comments | 0 Trackbacks

Rear-ended.

President O-bow-ma

November 14, 2009 09:34 PM by Michelle Malkin

184 Comments | 9 Trackbacks

Downward dog.


Categories: Barack Obama, National Service



Mudville Gazette

» The five-year plan

Gay Patriot

» The O So Hip Obama
Follow me on Twitter Follow me on Facebook