Oba-Kabuki: A box-office bomb

Photoshop credit: Applecross Media and Big Fur Hat
My syndicated column today is a theater review of yesterday’s Demcare talk-a-thon. What’s next? Here’s the rundown.
***
Oba-Kabuki: A box-office bomb
by Michelle Malkin
Creators Syndicate
Copyright 2010
The Oba-Kabuki health care show at Blair House kicked off with a big lie on Thursday morning – and it all went downhill from there. The taxpayer-funded infomercial backfired by exposing the president’s thin skin, the Democrats’ naked disingenuousness, and the ruling majority’s allergies to political and policy realities.
Responding to Sen. Lamar Alexander’s opening call for Democrats to renounce parliamentary tactics designed to limit debate, circumvent filibusters, and lower the threshold for passage of health care reform to a simple, 51-vote majority, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid sputtered indignantly: “No one’s talking about reconciliation!” Everybody and their mothers have been invoking the R-word on Capitol Hill, starting with Reid himself.
Four Democratic senators pushed Reid to adopt the procedure, normally reserved for budget matters, in a letter on Feb. 16. A few days later, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs discussed the option. And then Reid himself talked up reconciliation on a Nevada public affairs show as an option to ram the government health care takeover through in the next 60 days. According to The Hill, Reid said “congressional Democrats would likely opt for a procedural tactic in the Senate allowing the upper chamber to make final changes to its healthcare bill with only a simple majority of senators, instead of the 60 it takes to normally end a filibuster.” A few days after that, Reid snapped that Republicans “should stop crying” about the abrogation of Senate minority rights since the GOP had used the reconciliation process in the past.
So, the cleanest, most ethical, holier-than-thou Congress ever is now defending the unprecedented adoption of ramdown rules for a radical, multi-trillion-dollar program to usurp one-seventh of the economy on the grounds of two-wrongs-make-it-right? Hope and change, baby.
For his part, President Obama responded with one part pique and two parts diffidence. After the summit lunch break, Republicans pushed the reconciliation issue again in the face of the Democrats’ refusal to disavow the short-circuiting of the deliberative process. “The American people,” an annoyed Obama asserted, “are not all that interested in procedures inside the Senate.” Oh, really? A new USAToday/Gallup poll reports that 52 percent of Americans oppose using the procedural maneuver to pass the health care bill in the Senate on 51 votes rather than the 60 votes required to end any filibuster.
The survey also showed that Americans oppose Demcare-style health care “reform” by 49-42 – with those “strongly” opposed outnumbering those “strongly” in favor by 23% to 11%. Obama’s best and brightest team of Chicago strategists, new media gurus, and communications specialists still haven’t figured it out: Voters are as fed up with the corrupted process in Washington as they are with the White House’s overreaching policies. It’s both, stupid.
When he wasn’t cutting off Republicans who stuck to budget specifics and cited legislative page numbers and language instead of treacly, sob-story anecdotes involving dentures and gall stones, President Obama was filibustering the talk-a-thon away by invoking his daughters, rambling on about auto insurance, and sniping at former GOP presidential rival John McCain. “We’re not campaigning anymore,” lectured the perpetual campaigner-in-chief.
After ostentatiously disputing the GOP’s claims that health care premiums would rise under his plan, Obama walked it back. Confronted with more GOP pushback on the failure of Demcare to control costs, Obama told GOP Rep. Paul Ryan that he’d rather not “get bogged down in numbers.” Not numbers that he couldn’t cook on the spot without staff consultation, anyway.
Obama and the Democrats labored mightily to create the illusion of almost-there bipartisanship by repeatedly telling disagreeing Republicans that “we don’t disagree” and “there’s not a lot of difference” between us. But the dogs weren’t riding the ponies in this show.
This was a set-up from the start. The “we’re so close” mantra is the rhetorical wedge the White House will use to blame Republicans for fatal obstructionism, while whitewashing festering opposition from both pro-life Democrats who oppose the government funding of abortion services still in the plan and from left-wing progressives in the House who are clinging to a full, unadulterated public option.
While Republicans came off well and reasonably, the six-hour blowhard-fest was a monumental waste of time. Obamacare Theater tied up GOP energy and resources as the White House readies its “Plan B” (expanding government health care coverage, just at a slower pace) and Democrat leaders prep their reconciliation ramdown for early next week. This Washington box-office bomb is a prelude to much bigger legislative horrors still to come. Don’t you love farce?
See what others have said
Note from Michelle: This section is for comments from michellemalkin.com's community of registered readers. Please don't assume that I agree with or endorse any particular comment just because I let it stand. A reminder: Anyone who fails to comply with my terms of use may lose his or her posting privilege.
Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Catholic lawsuit against Obamacare mandate cites 1993 legislation written by Ted Kennedy and Chuck Schumer
May 22, 2012 04:35 PM by Doug Powers
48 CommentsIllinois Republicans flirting with cigarette tax hike for Obamacare — and a reminder about Orrin Hatch
May 21, 2012 11:03 AM by Michelle Malkin
32 CommentsHigh school fined $15,000 for… selling soda pop during lunch
May 19, 2012 01:29 PM by Doug Powers
101 CommentsDestroying private health insurance was always the goal
May 16, 2012 09:40 AM by Michelle Malkin
43 CommentsObamacare cronyism: The First Lady’s patient-dumping, privacy-meddling scheme
May 16, 2012 08:56 AM by Michelle Malkin
102 CommentsInsurers issuing new round of rebates must credit Obamacare
May 14, 2012 11:26 AM by Doug Powers
66 CommentsWhite House to SCOTUS: ‘Extraordinary disruptions’ to Medicare if Obamacare struck down
May 4, 2012 02:03 PM by Doug Powers
86 CommentsBiden predicts Supreme Court will uphold Obamacare
April 1, 2012 12:49 PM by Doug Powers
63 Comments
Categories: Health care

Pundit & Pundette
» Patterico's chilling account of harassment

Nice Deb
» The Organized Left Now Stalking Romney
Betsys Page
» Cruising the Web
NRO
» Unleash Biden!

NewsBusters.org
» Very Annoyed Matthews Rips ‘Horse’s Ass Right-Wingers’ Who Cite ‘Thrill Up My Leg,’ Calls C-SPAN Host a ‘Jackass’









I was just reading on Drudge about the new bill to give Obama the power to shut down the internet in case of “cyber emergency”. This is truly one of the most frightening things going on today.
I read some of the comments and actually copy/pasted a few of them because they bear repeating. Here they are:
“A nation can survive its fools and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and carries his banner openly. But the traitor moves amongst those within the gate freely, his sly whispers rustling through all the alleys, heard in the very halls of government itself. For the traitor appears not a traitor, he speaks in accents familiar to his victims, and he wears their face and their agreements, he appeals to the baseness that lies deep in the hearts of all men. He rots the soul of a nation, he works secretly and unknown in the night to undermine the pillars of the city, he infects the body politic so that it can no longer resist. A murderer is less to fear. The traitor is the plague.—Marcus Cicero
“Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same, or one day we will spend our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children what it was once like in the United States where men were free.”Ronald Reagan
“The Founding Fathers are screaming at us to water the tree of liberty.”
I am going to post these again on an open thread because they need to be seen by a lot of people!
The key is to force 2010 candidates to swear on their mothers’ graves that they will repeal this act once elected and then force them to do it once elected.
It’s that last part that will be difficult. “Our” side has been very unreliable and McCain ended his famous comments at the Oba-kabuki by agreeing with Obama that “both parties are very close to agreement”.
“Winning” in November guarantees nothing. Which Republican party will be in power after the elections? It better not be the “Gangs of McCain”.
Is that even possible? I mean, how do you get a massive bill like that repealed? I imagine there could be a lawsuit that it is unconstitutional and let the SCOTUS decide.
We can’t leave it to the pols to do this and we mustn’t lower our sights by trying to finesse this through court. It is absolutely critical that we decapitate this one-party government by targeting the top party leaders and working our way down, just like the Mafia and Al Qaeda.
McCain is enemy #1. Even Mark Levin is going wobbly by referring to people like us as “GOP haters”.
Machiavelli famously said “never wound a king”. If you can’t finish the job, don’t even start. If we do 2010 right, 2012 will be a victory march.
Allow me to improve my last comment.
“Machiavelli famously said “never wound a king”. If you
can’tdon’t have the stomach to finish the job, don’t even start.”Nullification has been tried before. The most famous being the Virginia and Kentucky resolutions. However, keep in mind that nullification itself, by states, is improper and illegal. Such decisions are decided by the SCOTUS, not by states, as provided for in the Constitution. If nullification was permitted, the result could be any state at any time, ignoring anything coming out of congress or the president. That would amount to anarchy by the states. Let SCOTUS decide if something is Constitutional, not state legislatures.
It is not improper or illegal – this is precisely the point. The very issue at hand is state sovereignty. According to the Tenth Amendment, the government of the United States has the power to regulate only matters delegated to it by the Constitution. Other powers are reserved to the states, or to the people. The Georgia ammendment challenges the constitutionality of Obamacare. If Congress does not back down, then it will be decided by SCOTUS.
No, the state can not simply ignore federal laws or presidential directives, but absolutely has the right – and obligation – to challenge the constitutionality and/or authority of federal actions adversely affecting its citizens. In GA, that would include me.
Gray – if the states may not challenge the feds, we are in deep weeds. Any sovereign state legislature can and must challenge the feds on abuse of constitutional authority. If the feds do not back down, then SCOTUS must resolve the question. The more states that do so re: Obamacare, the more strength the case has.
Is universal healthcare a constitutional right? Can a US citizen be forced to purchase health insurance under threat of federal prosecution? (Auto insurance is not a valid analogy – it protects other drivers) Can states – which as you pointed out have no money – be forced to pay for federally mandated healthcare? All valid constitutional questions.
My son is an attorney and we have discussed this ad nauseum over beers with his neighbor, a Georgia State Congressman. The Georgia ammendment is a valid means of challenging the constitutionality of Obamacare.
I actually saw a glimmer of hope show up. Beohner actually said “it’s un-Constitutional. There may be hope.
Bypassing the Byrd rule destroys the Senate. Turns America into Venezuela with just a few more easy steps.
I think we are agreeing but using different words. Georgia has the right to test the constitutionality of any federal law, in court. Perhaps I misunderstood what you were originally saying when you stated “nullification”. To simply ignore a federal law, because they didn’t like it, without challenge in court, is improper. Certainly states have the right to file suit in the federal court system and have, eventually, SCOTUS decide. It’s been done many times. Nullification has been used to just simply ignore the law, period. Such tactics would cause a mess in our legal system, with each state deciding what they will obey and not to obey. Might as well go back to the Articles of Confederation. If Georgia wants to challenge it, through our legal system, I give them credit and luck.
My soul is at rest knowing someone is on the case… with beers
What happens to the Progressives, if they can’t get universal health care passed? I mean what happens to the whole Progressive Movement. And what’s in it for George Soros?
gray – Actually, I don’t think we are on the same page. I am saying, a state has more than the right to challenge a federal law in court, it has certain sovereign powers which include enacting legislation and/or ammending its own constitution which are granted to it by the US constitution. Again, the US government may not regulate matters not delegated to it by the Constitution, and Obamacare clearly crosses over that line, on many levels. The state and federal laws are now in conflict, and unless the feds back down – THEN it goes to court. Nullification is not the intent, but is the outcome when a state makes a sovereign stand against what it perceives to be federal abuse of constitutional power, the very thing the constitution is designed to prevent. Congress may not enact laws infringing on the rights of states or individual citizens. Obamacare does just that.
The Tenth Ammendment Center has a good website that explains this better than I can. My guess is you will find nothing in there to disagree with.
Perhaps a good example of your concern may be Kahlifornia and 12 other states that have legalized “medical marijuana”, effectively “nullifying” federal law which makes mj illegal in virtually all circumstances. Instead of challenging the states, the DEA has backed off enforcement in those states. This could be an example of an abuse of “nullification” that I think justifies your point. The result empowers drug cartels, violates the rights of neighboring states and is detrimental to the country as a whole.
I didn’t want to make such a huge deal out of this, but this seems to be a way especially red states, like Georgia, can fight this monster. If it dies in congress it may be a moot point, but its looking more and more like they are going to try ram this giant turd down all our throats. This is one way to fight that has a good chance of succeeding.
I’ll withhold the name of said public official, but will reveal that he is an African American Reagan conservative who has no time for Dear Leader. He breaks up when we call him a racist. Oh, and he prefers Guiness Stout.
No Saturday open thread. Anyway, did everyone watch the “big” Tsunami hit Hawaii? If I was on the beach, I may not noticed it. Surfer delight for a few minutes.
Ditto…but I like mine cold.
I knew that was going to be another hyperventilating scare… much angst over nuttin’. What is it – 6000 miles away?
Indeed!!!
Hot Air’s Daffyd ab Hugh presents a very convincing argument that ObamaCare just doesn’t (and won’t) have the votes to pass.
Which makes me wonder if a lot of this bru-ha-ha isn’t more about making a lot of noise to appease the left-wing kooks. Once it fails, they roll up the circus tents and head out of town.
No offense but you might want to brush up on tsunami a bit…the wave got bigger as it approached Japan, after it passed Hawaii. Hundreds of people have died in Hawaii from tsunami generated in- yes – Chile and Alaska. This is a better safe than sorry story…
That, or maybe we could just water board the liberals.
I’m no expert on tsunami but since Hawaii is basically a very tall mountain surrounded by deep waters, aren’t tsunami most likely to pass right by barely noticed? Doesn’t it take a an gradually rising sea floor to concentrate the energy into a significant surge? Just asking. I don’t know.
America is not Europe, we are not a socialistic country or people.
This nation is founded on individualism and the individual’s inalienable rights, we don’t collect those rights and lock them away for use by the federal government.
We are not a gimmie people, we expect those who can do pull their own weight.
For a long time the federal government has lost its way and run its own agenda, that has to stop, all governments must mind their own business.
That’s the agenda, the whole point is to grow the welfare rolls..first you get people used to sucking on the government tit…it’s very hard to ween them back off. There is another message not getting play. When we hear in the news, that employment is going to stay flat for awhile…okay than how do people exist? Welfare. Comprehensive Welfare Reform is what Bill Clinton passed back in the 90s and now it’s all going to get undone because?
I believe that is what Daniel Hannan is attempting back in the UK with the establishment of their own TEA PARTY, ween the folks off the government tit.
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/danielhannan/100027366/british-tea-party-movement-to-launch-on-saturday/
I don’t know one thing that Sarah Palin warned us about during the campaign that hasn’t come to pass.
Excellent post. I have been coming to MM’s blog off and on today in hopes there would be an open thread. I don’t like to complain, but isn’t it relatively easy to open a thread and let us converse? I missed that this weekend! The open threads are always fun and full of new stuff. I hope MM is o.k. and just really really busy.
This is an open thread, and thanks.
MM deserves (richly) some relax time, she’ll be back, its in her DNA.
I hope she starts another HotAir and or some other conservatism expanding enterprise.
Yes, I agree it has been turned into an open thread. But I feel like I am going “off-topic” when I post on these thread that have topics!
Anyway, my comment wasn’t meant to be critical of our hostess. Of course she is busy and I appreciate all she does!! She is my hero.
The welfare state is the tool, anti freedom is the goal.
What part of no don’t the Democrats and the President get?
Liberals can’t govern, 14 months of kiss my ring does not constitute leadership but is very telling of a progressive future.
America is not a kingdom.
This thread having been officially declared open…someone was asking the other day what happened to Al Goricle. Well, he’s baaaaaaaaaaack. NYT today. Gorbot’s ignorance on climate science could easily fill several books he’s already written.
Whaaaa?? Ya gotta love the little feller. Just. Can’t. Cure. Stupid.
I didn’t think you were critical.
Offering a different perspective is the best contribution, in my opinion.
Watch those smilies, they can contain flat language bits of nasty.
I hope you don’t mean me cause I don’t have the authority to pay attention much less anything else.
Hitler Upset with Obama’s Healthcare Summit Performance
It’s relatively easy to get to safety by going higher up the mountain if you know a tsunami is on the way – and they have gotten much better at being able to warn everyone. Probably the most important thing is to get the thousands of tourists out of the water. Yesterday’s event was enough to have drowned people (IMO). The floor of the ocean does make some difference too (not an expert) and the wave got bigger as it approached Japan, probably for that reason. Local geography like harbors can also amplify the wave.
The reason i think even an event like yesterday could have drowned people is that the water recedes at an astonishing rate (they had a live cam on Hilo Bay, it looked like time-lapse photography) and rushes back in. Several times.
Hilo has had parts of the city wrecked twice, with hundreds dead in Hawaii in the 1946 and 1960 tsunamis, more for lack of warning than anything. Here are some photos from deadly tsunami in the past.
I’m familiar with tsunamis. My wife grew up under the threat of them, at any time, and I’ve seen the effects of them, over the centuries, studying history. I made a satirical statement on how the news built it up to an “OMG, Hawaii is going to be wiped out” type story. So we all glanced at the computer screen (FOX) at work, when we could, and ended up watching this wave being no more than 3 feet or so. There were a lot of “disappointed” thrillseekers on the cliffs, too.
Funny how Michelle disappears on the same day that Al Gore reappears. I wonder…
Don’t go there.
Experienced a tsunami yesterday. Drain line came loose on the washer. Soapy tsunami down the hallway. No deaths or injuries, but some language not befitting a Christian reported.
Film at 11.
First golf of the season today! 57 degrees and sunny. Walked 9 holes.
Fairways: Soggy – no roll
Greens: Brown. Like cow pastures
Time with son: Priceless
Swede, you need a tsunami warning center by your washroom, with a siren. Of course, if that doesn’t work, go golfing. For me, I had Friday-Sunday scheduled off work. Saturday, I got the “How soon can you get here?” call, and today, at 12:10, the same thing. Glad I’m so valuable…sigh. Rather be golfing.
I always support Michelle in her wanting to spend time with family. Kids grow up so quickly. We can make our own open thread and talk about the news. As far as Al Gore and his bunch is concerned, we could have England covered in glaciers, with a massive glacier moving down Wall Street in NYC, and Gore would proclaim it is all due to global warming, with Oslo agreeing, setting up a new Peace Prize for him.
I wonder how Al Gore feels about having been declared the first “green” billionaire a few weeks ago only to have his “green empire” evaporate in the bat of an eye.
“You can’t just wish climate change away, just because the facts and the science don’t support my arguments, well, harrumph… I mean…. I USED TO BE A BILLIONAIRE!!!”
The goracle never fails to amuse! I want him to just keep talking because it is great theatre and he no longer can do any harm. One thing I would like to see, though, is manbearpig in jail. And broke.
Beautiful “warm” day here in Minnesota. My grandson rode his big wheel in the driveway, which has finally melted. There is hope. I expect to see the crocuses poke through the ground next to the house shortly. That happens sometime early March. Then they get a really pretty coating of snow. Also, today is the last day to get your ice houses off the lakes. That is a sure sign of spring!
I’m looking forward to hearing Rush Limbaugh tomorrow. Mondays are always fun because he uses sound bites from the weekend “news” shows and then comments on how ridiculous these progressives sound.
Hey you bunch of thread highjackers!
Huh. Seems I always get “How soon can you leave.” Between being important and golfing with the kids…guess I’ll go with “D’Oh!”
I always thought ice fishing was some form of neurological disorder – yet I was out there freezing my @$$ off every winter. My son says I froze all but two brain cells, so I need to be careful with those.
Uh..yeah! Leave the children to their own devices and…
Whaddya bet our very British Ms. Kay goes to a “37th ranked” US doctor, clinic or hospital every time she needs health care! http://newsbusters.org/blogs/mark-finkelstein/2010/02/28/sick-canadian-should-have-gone-costa-rica
Make sure you fill in the holes too. Don’t want anyone falling in by accident. They are hard to see after the ice melts.
*I hope all is well with Michelle and family; When gone for an extended period, we are usually whipped into shape by Doug Powers, cousin of Austin Powers.
*Regarding Demcare, all indications are that they will push something through, and we already know that it will be bad; They seem to think that it will only lead to a short term election setback come November; They are wrong; It will roil the markets, the economy, economic indicators, and could very well lead to a nationwide tax revolt; It will put us on the brink, and it didn’t have to come to this at all.
Once this healthcare plan is in effect, the dems will use it as the new “3rd rail” of politics. Any attempt to change it, or get rid of it, will be attacked as taking away benefits from the “poor” and “working class”. That is why they want to pass it right now. It will give them the “edge”, they hope, in elections in the future. The real effect of this bill won’t even go into effect until 2012. That way, the main elections are over.
Now that there is funny!!
Errah, By now old news. Where in the world is Al Gwhore? I see he has a new opinion piece in the NY Slimes. Do they have fax machines at the beach resort where he’s been staying? Amazing the NY Slimes could get through the snow to publish his lunatic rant on AWG Man Bear Pig. Oh BTW and it comes as no surprise that the NYT has no comment section on their page to refute his nonsense.