|
|
Kennedy and McCain introduce massive illegal alien amnesty plan
By
Chris Kelly
· May 12, 2005 06:51 PM
Sens. McCain and Kennedy have introduced the "2005 Secure America and Orderly Immigration Act". They were joined by Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-IL), Jeff Flake (R-AZ), and Jim Kolbe (R-AZ). Kennedy specifically denies that this is an "amnesty", but any difference between SAOIA and amnesty is purely semantic. Expect semantics - or, more properly, doublespeak - to be a major part of the debate on this bill. Reports on the bill are in "Bill would tighten border security, increase information sharing", "Bills could grant legality to 10 million immigrants". Kennedy's press release has a detailed description of the bill. Rep. J.D. Hayworth (R-AZ) issued a statement opposing the bill, including this: ...If recent history is an accurate guide, and I believe it is, this so-called guest worker notion would only encourage a new wave of illegal aliens and make America's uncontrolled and unacceptable immigration debacle even worse than it is now. Meanwhile those in favor of the bill have issued their own press releases. (Click the links for background on the groups mentioned.) The press release from FIRM ("Fair Immmigration Reform Movement") contains this statement from FIRM organizer Deepak Bhargava: For too long Americans have benefited from the hard work of millions of law-abiding undocumented workers that have had to endure a life of fear of deportation and discrimination. FIRM is a project of the Center for Community Change, and Bhargava is the executive director of that latter group. One of the members of FIRM's organizing committee is Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles. The Service Employees International Union issued a press release in support of SAOIA here. The National Restaurant Association's press release is here. It includes a statement from "Lee Culpepper, the Association's senior vice president of Government Affairs and Public Policy and Chairman of the National Immigration Forum." The page "Organizations Supporting Amnesty for Illegal Aliens" contains a 2002 quote from Culpepper, which sounds similar to something you've probably heard many times from another source: ...we believe that our nation's immigration policy should not only secure our borders, but also match willing employers with willing employees... In an interesting twist, the Laborers' International Union issued a statement favoring the bill, but moderately opposing its guest worker provisions: "In light of abuses that have historically occurred with guest worker programs, we believe the provisions in this bill for H5A visas should be improved to ensure that workers have legal recourse against unscrupulous employers and so that U.S. workers are protected from employers whose sole purpose in hiring H5A visa holders is to undercut existing workplace standards," [Terence M. O'Sullivan, General President of the Laborers' Union] said. UPDATE: Continuing our guilt-by-association but entirely-justified tour, the office of Mexico's Foreign Minister Luis Ernesto Derbez has issued a statement. From "Mexico eyes immigration politicking": "According to the preliminary information that we have, this initiative...supports substantive elements and distinct aspects of the migratory problem that reflect a serious interest and a political determination to adopt a balanced and integral focus on the treatment of the migratory issue and to tackle the issue of security from a wider context." |